2006 Z Safety Review
#5
Originally Posted by NOBI
thank you race inspired design.
#7
Originally Posted by Blue Komodo
The Z shares it's chassis with the Murano (a frickin SUV), FX35/45, G35 coupe/sedan. If the Z/G had it's own dedicated chassis, it would be lighter and it would handle better. My STI handled way better than my Z, and the steering provided FAR more feedback (both on JIC's).
I believe all this has been discussed before in previous posts.
Trending Topics
#8
Originally Posted by risin
I believe the murano shares its platform with the altima. The z,g, and fx share the same platform but just because it does does not mean that the z has a platform that was designed for an suv. The fx and murano are suv but built on car platforms. The z weighs about 3200 lbs and that is pretty light for a sports car the size of a z with a v6. I believe the 350 weighs less than the previous z.
I believe all this has been discussed before in previous posts.
I believe all this has been discussed before in previous posts.
#9
Originally Posted by Blue Komodo
You may be right about the Murano, it is FWD. However the Z is not lite by any means, it weighs 3400lbs due to the platform sharing, which makes it a heavy pig. If Nissan had given the Z it's own dedicated chassis it would'nt have been compromised (beefed up to support the extra weight of the FX), it could weigh 3 or 4 hundred pounds less and be a way better performer. 2900lbs is lite for a sports car like the C6Z06 with a v8, different price range I know but the point remains. The Z was meant to be cash cow, it brought Nissan from the verge of bankruptcy with it's platform shared, compromised chassis. Just like it was meant to do. My mechanic/tuner is a Z expert, he says 300 was far better built than the 350. If Nissan wanted to make a world class sports car, they would have built it on an aluminum space frame like Honda did with the S2000. My roadster weighs 3600lbs, and the chassis creaks and flexes whenever I go over anything bigger than a pebble.
We cant compare the Z to the Z06 ... the Z06's body panels are made of fiberglass, hence why it is light for a V8 car.
The Acura NSX, which is made mostly out of Aluminum, is about 3100lbs. The 350Z Coupe (at 3200 lbs) is only 100+lbs heavier, not bad at all. Plus it is lighter than the 300ZX, which had its own dedicated chasis.
The coupe at 3200lbs is not too bad ... but I have to agree with you on the roadster's weight of 3400lbs is a little on the heavy side. You quoted 3600lbs for the roadster ... is that for the new 06 model? Hmmm that seems quite high.
Also, there is no creak or flex in the coupe, the roadster will not be as rigid as the coupe because of the loss of the roof.
As far as Nissan making a world class sports car --- that title I think is reserved for the upcoming 2007 GT-R.
Last edited by Tweety-nator; 08-08-2005 at 10:58 AM.
#11
I find the chassis of the ZR to be very stiff for a roadster (which I assumed was due to the excessive weight). I'm surprised to hear someone say they find the chassis flexing.
Originally Posted by Blue Komodo
You may be right about the Murano, it is FWD. However the Z is not lite by any means, it weighs 3400lbs due to the platform sharing, which makes it a heavy pig. If Nissan had given the Z it's own dedicated chassis it would'nt have been compromised (beefed up to support the extra weight of the FX), it could weigh 3 or 4 hundred pounds less and be a way better performer. 2900lbs is lite for a sports car like the C6Z06 with a v8, different price range I know but the point remains. The Z was meant to be cash cow, it brought Nissan from the verge of bankruptcy with it's platform shared, compromised chassis. Just like it was meant to do. My mechanic/tuner is a Z expert, he says 300 was far better built than the 350. If Nissan wanted to make a world class sports car, they would have built it on an aluminum space frame like Honda did with the S2000. My roadster weighs 3600lbs, and the chassis creaks and flexes whenever I go over anything bigger than a pebble.
#12
Originally Posted by Jason
The real question is - the sharing of the chassis has made the Z a poor car HOW? It seems to be: highly capable, fast, and sells well regardless.
Perfomance m6 = 3401lbs
a5 = 3381lbs
Grand Touring Coupe m6 = 3405lbs
a5 = 3391lbs
Roadster m6 = 3601lbs
a5 = 3599lbs
Komodo.
#13
Let's compare.
Track MT = 3225
BMW M5 (06) = 3868
Audi S4 (05) = 3659
Nissan 300ZX TT (93) = 3533
Toyota Supra (95) = 3515
BMW M3 (05) = 3415
Dodge Viper SRT10 (04) = 3385
Ford GT (05) = 3350
Subaru WRX STi (06) = 3351
Mitsu Lancer (06) = 3285
Acura NSX (05) = 3152
Ferrari 360 (02) = 3064
Well... I dunno, seems like the Z compares pretty well to me.
I'm also afraid that your weights don't jive with other published weights:
http://www.rsportscars.com/eng/cars/...0zroadster.asp
http://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/Mo...20563|,00.html
http://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/Mo...20564|,00.html
Track MT = 3225
BMW M5 (06) = 3868
Audi S4 (05) = 3659
Nissan 300ZX TT (93) = 3533
Toyota Supra (95) = 3515
BMW M3 (05) = 3415
Dodge Viper SRT10 (04) = 3385
Ford GT (05) = 3350
Subaru WRX STi (06) = 3351
Mitsu Lancer (06) = 3285
Acura NSX (05) = 3152
Ferrari 360 (02) = 3064
Well... I dunno, seems like the Z compares pretty well to me.
I'm also afraid that your weights don't jive with other published weights:
http://www.rsportscars.com/eng/cars/...0zroadster.asp
http://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/Mo...20563|,00.html
http://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/Mo...20564|,00.html
#14
Originally Posted by maxpowers
I find the chassis of the ZR to be very stiff for a roadster (which I assumed was due to the excessive weight). I'm surprised to hear someone say they find the chassis flexing.
#15
Originally Posted by Blue Komodo
You may be right about the Murano, it is FWD. However the Z is not lite by any means, it weighs 3400lbs due to the platform sharing, which makes it a heavy pig. If Nissan had given the Z it's own dedicated chassis it would'nt have been compromised (beefed up to support the extra weight of the FX), it could weigh 3 or 4 hundred pounds less and be a way better performer. 2900lbs is lite for a sports car like the C6Z06 with a v8, different price range I know but the point remains.
Even the Ferrari Challenge Stradale and Porsche GT3 are supposed lightweighted sports cars, they weigh close to 3000lbs. Even the Enzo or Carrera GT weigh somewhere close to 3250lbs.
So the Z weighing around 3200lbs is not bad at all. And the rule of thumb is every 2 cylinder increases the weight of the car by around 200lbs, I think that includes increased weight in drivetrain and chassis mass.
IMHO By not sharing the platform and to make enough profit on the S2000 or the NSX, Honda needed to keep the models unchanged for a long time. NSX came out in 91 and Honda recently stopped the production. S2000 came in '99 and is still in production, no major changes other than the engine and some minor tweaks.
Last edited by spacemn_spiff; 08-08-2005 at 01:24 PM.
#16
Originally Posted by Jason
Let's compare.
Track MT = 3225
BMW M5 (06) = 3868
Audi S4 (05) = 3659
Nissan 300ZX TT (93) = 3533
Toyota Supra (95) = 3515
BMW M3 (05) = 3415
Dodge Viper SRT10 (04) = 3385
Ford GT (05) = 3350
Subaru WRX STi (06) = 3351
Mitsu Lancer (06) = 3285
Acura NSX (05) = 3152
Ferrari 360 (02) = 3064
Well... I dunno, seems like the Z compares pretty well to me.
I'm also afraid that your weights don't jive with other published weights:
http://www.rsportscars.com/eng/cars/...0zroadster.asp
http://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/Mo...20563|,00.html
http://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/Mo...20564|,00.html
Track MT = 3225
BMW M5 (06) = 3868
Audi S4 (05) = 3659
Nissan 300ZX TT (93) = 3533
Toyota Supra (95) = 3515
BMW M3 (05) = 3415
Dodge Viper SRT10 (04) = 3385
Ford GT (05) = 3350
Subaru WRX STi (06) = 3351
Mitsu Lancer (06) = 3285
Acura NSX (05) = 3152
Ferrari 360 (02) = 3064
Well... I dunno, seems like the Z compares pretty well to me.
I'm also afraid that your weights don't jive with other published weights:
http://www.rsportscars.com/eng/cars/...0zroadster.asp
http://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/Mo...20563|,00.html
http://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/Mo...20564|,00.html
#17
ferrari enzo's weigh 2767 lbs
the C6 Z06 weighs 3130 lbs
regular C6 weighs 3179 lbs
base model Z weighs 3188 lbs, track weighs 3225 lbs
the 35th aniversary/grand touring is about 100 lbs heavier
roadster is about 200 lbs heavier
grand touring roadster is 3,536 lbs. Now that is pig heavy
You can get a Z to weigh less with aftermarket parts. I'm not so sure how much less you can make a Z06 since everything on it is already pretty lightweight. The engine in it weighs about 100 lbs more than the Z engine
I agree the Z is heavy in it's own right, but compared to other stuff out there it's not that bad. Even STI's and EVO's weigh more than the Z, but they have 4 seats...and their chasis is still not as stiff. Yeah they might handle better, but that's because of other reasons, not the chasis so much
My Z weighs around 3100 lbs with a half tank of gas
weighs around 3060 without spare tire/tools
the C6 Z06 weighs 3130 lbs
regular C6 weighs 3179 lbs
base model Z weighs 3188 lbs, track weighs 3225 lbs
the 35th aniversary/grand touring is about 100 lbs heavier
roadster is about 200 lbs heavier
grand touring roadster is 3,536 lbs. Now that is pig heavy
You can get a Z to weigh less with aftermarket parts. I'm not so sure how much less you can make a Z06 since everything on it is already pretty lightweight. The engine in it weighs about 100 lbs more than the Z engine
I agree the Z is heavy in it's own right, but compared to other stuff out there it's not that bad. Even STI's and EVO's weigh more than the Z, but they have 4 seats...and their chasis is still not as stiff. Yeah they might handle better, but that's because of other reasons, not the chasis so much
My Z weighs around 3100 lbs with a half tank of gas
weighs around 3060 without spare tire/tools
#18
Originally Posted by spcemn_spiff
I think its early to speak of C6 ZO6, I will wait till it comes out for actual numbers (it is supposed to be around 3100lbs). But the C5 ZO6 weighed more than 3100lbs. There are very few cars that weigh less than 3000 lbs and still be normal sized cars, well you have tiny cars like Lotus Elise that weighs 1980 lbs.
Even the Ferrari Challenge Stradale and Porsche GT3 are supposed lightweighted sports cars, they weigh close to 3000lbs. Even the Enzo or Carrera GT weigh somewhere close to 3250lbs.
So the Z weighing around 3200lbs is not bad at all. And the rule of thumb is every 2 cylinder increases the weight of the car by around 200lbs, I think that includes increased weight in drivetrain and chassis mass.
IMHO By not sharing the platform and to make enough profit on the S2000 or the NSX, Honda needed to keep the models unchanged for a long time. NSX came out in 91 and Honda recently stopped the production. S2000 came in '99 and is still in production, no major changes other than the engine and some minor tweaks.
Even the Ferrari Challenge Stradale and Porsche GT3 are supposed lightweighted sports cars, they weigh close to 3000lbs. Even the Enzo or Carrera GT weigh somewhere close to 3250lbs.
So the Z weighing around 3200lbs is not bad at all. And the rule of thumb is every 2 cylinder increases the weight of the car by around 200lbs, I think that includes increased weight in drivetrain and chassis mass.
IMHO By not sharing the platform and to make enough profit on the S2000 or the NSX, Honda needed to keep the models unchanged for a long time. NSX came out in 91 and Honda recently stopped the production. S2000 came in '99 and is still in production, no major changes other than the engine and some minor tweaks.
#19
can you imagine how much more expensive the Z would be with it's own chasis built on an aluminum space frame?
A cheaper and safer way to lose weight would be to use fiberglass body panels instead of aluminum. At least that'd save maybe 100 lbs
A cheaper and safer way to lose weight would be to use fiberglass body panels instead of aluminum. At least that'd save maybe 100 lbs
#20
Originally Posted by sentry65
ferrari enzo's weigh 2767 lbs
http://motortrend.com/roadtests/coup...ro/index5.html
It weighs 3254lbs, curb weight.
Originally Posted by Blue Komodo
I hear what your saying, but there's no need to change the chassis if it's already state of the art. Can you imagine how much better the Z would be with it's own chassis built on an aluminum space frame?
If you are talking about handling, you can make the Z handle 1.0g on skidpad with very inexpensive mods.
Last edited by spacemn_spiff; 08-08-2005 at 02:03 PM.