Are they planning a 370Z Roadster?
Trending Topics
I hope Nissan does a good job with the roadster this time. From whatever reviews/impressions I've seen or heard or read, the 350Z roadster was a heavy, rolling, cowl-shaking mess. Whatever accolades the coupe would earn in comparison tests, the roadster would negate. It gave the 350Z a bad name, esp. when compared against roadsters that were designed as convertibles from the ground up, like the S2K and BMW Z4.
Originally Posted by gocart
I hope Nissan does a good job with the roadster this time. From whatever reviews/impressions I've seen or heard or read, the 350Z roadster was a heavy, rolling, cowl-shaking mess. Whatever accolades the coupe would earn in comparison tests, the roadster would negate. It gave the 350Z a bad name, esp. when compared against roadsters that were designed as convertibles from the ground up, like the S2K and BMW Z4.
Originally Posted by KombatKing
Well as long as we are churning the rumor mill... I've read online that there may be a a hard top convertible 370Z...

~KK

~KK
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (4)
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 5,587
Likes: 4
From: Charlotte, NC
Originally Posted by gocart
I hope Nissan does a good job with the roadster this time. From whatever reviews/impressions I've seen or heard or read, the 350Z roadster was a heavy, rolling, cowl-shaking mess. Whatever accolades the coupe would earn in comparison tests, the roadster would negate. It gave the 350Z a bad name, esp. when compared against roadsters that were designed as convertibles from the ground up, like the S2K and BMW Z4.
As for the Hard Top Convertable, with that new roof-line, it certainly seems doable..
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (4)
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 5,587
Likes: 4
From: Charlotte, NC
Originally Posted by Apexi350z
a converter hard top will probably be over $45k 

Originally Posted by gocart
I hope Nissan does a good job with the roadster this time. From whatever reviews/impressions I've seen or heard or read, the 350Z roadster was a heavy, rolling, cowl-shaking mess. Whatever accolades the coupe would earn in comparison tests, the roadster would negate. It gave the 350Z a bad name, esp. when compared against roadsters that were designed as convertibles from the ground up, like the S2K and BMW Z4.
Originally Posted by mx48
WTF are you talking about-cowl shaking -not at all-rolling-please explain- heavy - ok do to the convertible hardware, What comparison tests are you talking about that drop the perfomance vs the coupe
Coupe:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=41GWmcMK7jc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C96eTL4eghw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SntY4qLd0c
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qeQkhmAkaoY
Roadster:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BckIIwNhdBk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-t96uOZPkhc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIcqiXjI6WQ
The last Coupe link is not a comparo but an isolated test of the 07 Coupe. It does, however, show just how much the car is liked by the Fifth Gear team. Vicki declared it to be one of the best cars ever made. The last Roadster link is from a shootout that was aired a little after the 07 Coupe review, and I was pretty surprised to see how much the tides turned when the car went from coupe to roadster form.
These reviews are by no means exhaustive. I am sure you could find coupe comparisons where the 350z fared poorly, and you could probably find roadster shootouts that the Z won. You could also argue that there doesn't exist any direct coupe-vs-roadster comparison test.
However, the general picture that I personally built up from watching/reading a bunch of reviews and shootouts was that the coupe was universally liked when compared against its peers (Audi TT, Evo, STi, Stang GT) , while the roadster was generally disliked when put up against its own peers (S2K, Z4). The fact that the roadster belongs in a significantly higher price bracket probably has a lot to do with this.



