20's....the good and the bad
#41
I have 20's and stock brakes. It still brakes good. I have not noticed any problems with the braking. Like bignate7
said before different strokes for different folks. It's all about what you want. It's your money so do with it as you please.
said before different strokes for different folks. It's all about what you want. It's your money so do with it as you please.
#42
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Tampa, Fl
Posts: 153
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by ALong
Like I said before, its down to personal choice. Just dont confuse 20" wheels with performance, some people seem to think bigger is better but that is not always true. One thing is for certain you will need to get a big brake kit front and rear for the car. It just plain looks silly having 20" wheels with the stock brakes.......
Like I said before, its down to personal choice. Just dont confuse 20" wheels with performance, some people seem to think bigger is better but that is not always true. One thing is for certain you will need to get a big brake kit front and rear for the car. It just plain looks silly having 20" wheels with the stock brakes.......
#43
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Orange County, CA
Posts: 5,007
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just to drop my $0.02, larger rims are generally designed to allow for larger brakes. For people with the stock 17", that can be a pretty big deal.
I'm personally about to setup a set of 19" ro_ja with some b!tchin summer tires, and keep my 17" rims with some all-seasons for my winter tire (not like we get much winter in SoCal, but whatever). . . My biggest reason for not going with 20"s (and why I almost went with 18") is tire prices... Looking @ 17" tires I can pickup a set of decent tires for $500. At 18"s your talking minimum $700. At 19's its about $800-1000. 20's just get even more out of hand (1k - 2k)... Too much money on rubber IMO. And for hard summer driving on Z rated tires, expect only to get about 12k miles out of your thousand bucks...
I'm personally about to setup a set of 19" ro_ja with some b!tchin summer tires, and keep my 17" rims with some all-seasons for my winter tire (not like we get much winter in SoCal, but whatever). . . My biggest reason for not going with 20"s (and why I almost went with 18") is tire prices... Looking @ 17" tires I can pickup a set of decent tires for $500. At 18"s your talking minimum $700. At 19's its about $800-1000. 20's just get even more out of hand (1k - 2k)... Too much money on rubber IMO. And for hard summer driving on Z rated tires, expect only to get about 12k miles out of your thousand bucks...
#45
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Tampa, Fl
Posts: 153
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by mysilverz33
NOZ...I'm getting that same wheel setup...what kind of springs are you running...looks great
NOZ...I'm getting that same wheel setup...what kind of springs are you running...looks great
#49
Registered User
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Seattle
Posts: 468
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not to beat a dead horse but you are still missing the point. First you do not get a larger contact patch with a 20" wheel/tire. A 17/18/19/20 wheel with the same width tire and same overall diameter is going to have the same contact patch, please re-read the previous post above that listed the tire size comparison.
In the past., yes 18" or 19" were the range among those who wanted bling. For people wanting performance, 18" was the max. It was enough to clear big brakes but still remain lightweight.
The ALMS Lolas use 18" wheels. Yes the Carrera GT has a 20" wheel, but it is a superlightweight magnesium wheel and they went with the 20" wheel for looks.
Yes 20" wheels affect the performance, they do reduce acceleration, braking and corning to a degree. The only way a 20" wheel would not lower performance is if you found a wheel and tire as light, if not lighter than a lightweight 18" wheel.
Bottom line is if you want 20" wheels get them for the looks, but dont think you are increasing the performance of the car with 20" wheels.
In the past., yes 18" or 19" were the range among those who wanted bling. For people wanting performance, 18" was the max. It was enough to clear big brakes but still remain lightweight.
The ALMS Lolas use 18" wheels. Yes the Carrera GT has a 20" wheel, but it is a superlightweight magnesium wheel and they went with the 20" wheel for looks.
Yes 20" wheels affect the performance, they do reduce acceleration, braking and corning to a degree. The only way a 20" wheel would not lower performance is if you found a wheel and tire as light, if not lighter than a lightweight 18" wheel.
Bottom line is if you want 20" wheels get them for the looks, but dont think you are increasing the performance of the car with 20" wheels.
#50
Registered User
iTrader: (14)
I don't think anyone on this board really thinks 20's will increase performance. In fact I wouldn't even look at aftermarket wheels for performance gains. Engine mods is what most people really look to for performance gains.
I myself am getting 20's for the looks. The G35 is fast enough for me, and if I ever track the car on a road course I would buy some 17s.
I myself am getting 20's for the looks. The G35 is fast enough for me, and if I ever track the car on a road course I would buy some 17s.
#52
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Tampa, Fl
Posts: 153
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by moog
I don't think anyone on this board really thinks 20's will increase performance. In fact I wouldn't even look at aftermarket wheels for performance gains. Engine mods is what most people really look to for performance gains.
I myself am getting 20's for the looks. The G35 is fast enough for me, and if I ever track the car on a road course I would buy some 17s.
I don't think anyone on this board really thinks 20's will increase performance. In fact I wouldn't even look at aftermarket wheels for performance gains. Engine mods is what most people really look to for performance gains.
I myself am getting 20's for the looks. The G35 is fast enough for me, and if I ever track the car on a road course I would buy some 17s.
#53
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Tampa, Fl
Posts: 153
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by NOZ4U
You hit the nail right on the head.
You hit the nail right on the head.
Also on a side note.... the same factor holds true when it comes to big brake kits. Everyone wants to get big brake kits for "looks" but seem to forget that it's considered unsprung weight. A heavier/larger rotor will require more power to turn. However at the point in which I would technically need a big brake kit (not needed for daily driving) weight would be an issue i.e. tracking the car. ALong, as stated before, you do have very valid points and if my car was a straight up track car, weight would be my biggest concern. But most cars are daily drivers with the occasional blast between red lights. If we put it in perspective......someone who has a straight-up track car could come to someone who owns a 350Z and question why the car(which some take to the track) has air conditioning, plush leather/cloth seats, a radio, sound dampening materials, a dashboard, BODY KITS, carpeting......airbags (for christ sake why would a race car have airbags?). The reasoning is because it's not a race car. We need some creature comforts to make it driveable and thus we begin a compromise. Unless you have a 350Z that spends every minute of it's life on a race track, it's still a sports car.....and such a beautiful one at that.
I'm not quite sure how you're saying it's not a larger tread width because the specs from Bridgestone's site says that it is.....But I'm not really concerned with it. If everything else is compensated to work with a 20in wheel, handling can be improved or maintained. By just slapping on a 20in wheel and thinking everything is just as stock is retarted and I don't think anyone has that perception. But if you wanted the wheel, other changes can be made to accomodate the larger wheel and it's adverse affects on performance. Besides if at some point someone's running some type of TT or SC, the addtional weight of a 20in wheel won't amount to anything. When I replaced my wheels, the stock wheels (without tires) weighed 23lbs FR and 24lbs RR. My new wheels weighed 25lbs FR and 26.5lbs RR. That's not that big of a difference. The tire were 4lbs heavier but that can all be compensated for and it has been. Granted, if I was putting 300hp to the wheels with 20's, I realize I could be getting better times with 18's 19's or why not 17's or 16's but I like the look of the 20's. Besides.....there's always ALWAYS someone faster. This is not meant to be any type of flame, I'm just trying to give my opinon on 20's
#54
Registered User
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Seattle
Posts: 468
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
NOZ4U,
I know you are not trying to flame and I am not either. What I am trying to do is use my experience to educate you guys and correct some misconceptions when it comes to wheels and tires. Please look at my previous post where I listed tire diameters and section widths. The section width info shows that a 20" tire compared to the same size tire in 17/18/19 has the same section width (ie: tread width) so you get no more tread width on a 20" than you do on a "smaller" tire. It is a very common misconception that "going bigger is better" and that a 20" tire is somehow wider than a smaller tire. This is just not true.
Personally, if I had a strict "street" only car, I would put 19" on it for the looks (personally I think 20" are too big looking for the 350Z). If I owned a G35 Coupe, I would put 20" on that, I think the larger wheelbase on the G35 and bigger overall shape make the 20" wheels the way to go visually on that car.
Everybody has their own wants, needs and opinions. Nothing wrong with a 20" if thats what you want.
I just hope everyone has read the technical information that I have provided and maybe has learned something about upsprung weight, tire section width and overall diameter.
I know you are not trying to flame and I am not either. What I am trying to do is use my experience to educate you guys and correct some misconceptions when it comes to wheels and tires. Please look at my previous post where I listed tire diameters and section widths. The section width info shows that a 20" tire compared to the same size tire in 17/18/19 has the same section width (ie: tread width) so you get no more tread width on a 20" than you do on a "smaller" tire. It is a very common misconception that "going bigger is better" and that a 20" tire is somehow wider than a smaller tire. This is just not true.
Personally, if I had a strict "street" only car, I would put 19" on it for the looks (personally I think 20" are too big looking for the 350Z). If I owned a G35 Coupe, I would put 20" on that, I think the larger wheelbase on the G35 and bigger overall shape make the 20" wheels the way to go visually on that car.
Everybody has their own wants, needs and opinions. Nothing wrong with a 20" if thats what you want.
I just hope everyone has read the technical information that I have provided and maybe has learned something about upsprung weight, tire section width and overall diameter.
#55
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Canada B.C.
Posts: 1,204
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by ALong
NOZ4U,
I know you are not trying to flame and I am not either. What I am trying to do is use my experience to educate you guys and correct some misconceptions when it comes to wheels and tires. Please look at my previous post where I listed tire diameters and section widths. The section width info shows that a 20" tire compared to the same size tire in 17/18/19 has the same section width (ie: tread width) so you get no more tread width on a 20" than you do on a "smaller" tire. It is a very common misconception that "going bigger is better" and that a 20" tire is somehow wider than a smaller tire. This is just not true.
Personally, if I had a strict "street" only car, I would put 19" on it for the looks (personally I think 20" are too big looking for the 350Z). If I owned a G35 Coupe, I would put 20" on that, I think the larger wheelbase on the G35 and bigger overall shape make the 20" wheels the way to go visually on that car.
Everybody has their own wants, needs and opinions. Nothing wrong with a 20" if thats what you want.
I just hope everyone has read the technical information that I have provided and maybe has learned something about upsprung weight, tire section width and overall diameter.
NOZ4U,
I know you are not trying to flame and I am not either. What I am trying to do is use my experience to educate you guys and correct some misconceptions when it comes to wheels and tires. Please look at my previous post where I listed tire diameters and section widths. The section width info shows that a 20" tire compared to the same size tire in 17/18/19 has the same section width (ie: tread width) so you get no more tread width on a 20" than you do on a "smaller" tire. It is a very common misconception that "going bigger is better" and that a 20" tire is somehow wider than a smaller tire. This is just not true.
Personally, if I had a strict "street" only car, I would put 19" on it for the looks (personally I think 20" are too big looking for the 350Z). If I owned a G35 Coupe, I would put 20" on that, I think the larger wheelbase on the G35 and bigger overall shape make the 20" wheels the way to go visually on that car.
Everybody has their own wants, needs and opinions. Nothing wrong with a 20" if thats what you want.
I just hope everyone has read the technical information that I have provided and maybe has learned something about upsprung weight, tire section width and overall diameter.
the tire width is the key when cornering.
not the "siz" of the rims.
and from reading all the post in the thread, i think along is just trying to say that a lightweight 20" rims won't have a advantage over a lightweight 19" or lightweight 18" in from a performance point of view.(no to say adding other mods)
#56
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Tampa, Fl
Posts: 153
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think there might have been some misunderstanding somewhere in these posts. I'm aware that a 275 tire with a rim diameter of 20in is the same as a 275 tire with a rim diamter of 17, 18, or 19in. It's 275mm or 10.82in. My point of contention was I wanted a wider tire than the 235/50 and with out making the car look gawdy with a 285/40/17, I would need to go with a lower aspect ratio thus compensating with a bigger wheel. So as it stands now, I do have a larger contact path than my stock tires, the car doesn't have a huge sidewall and I got a kick ***
20in wheel to boot. Is performace increased....no, but I do have a larger tire that sticks better and corners better than stock. Like I previously stated, my only enemy is weight which can and is being overcome by engine mods and drivetrain mods....or by purchasing the Axis Seven modular lightweight 3 piece$$$$$ Well maybe just for the rears
20in wheel to boot. Is performace increased....no, but I do have a larger tire that sticks better and corners better than stock. Like I previously stated, my only enemy is weight which can and is being overcome by engine mods and drivetrain mods....or by purchasing the Axis Seven modular lightweight 3 piece$$$$$ Well maybe just for the rears
#57
Registered User
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Seattle
Posts: 468
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
NOZ4U,
I see what you are now saying, yes the 20" wheels/tires are bigger than your stock wheels. As far as the look of the 17" they do actually look good on a lowered Z, take a look at pictures of the 350EVO and Performance Racing 350Z race cars, both have 17" front/rear wheel/tires.
GYZ, what suspension did you decide to get? Are you going with the Ohlins? I am still waiting for my JRZ's to arrive.....
I see what you are now saying, yes the 20" wheels/tires are bigger than your stock wheels. As far as the look of the 17" they do actually look good on a lowered Z, take a look at pictures of the 350EVO and Performance Racing 350Z race cars, both have 17" front/rear wheel/tires.
GYZ, what suspension did you decide to get? Are you going with the Ohlins? I am still waiting for my JRZ's to arrive.....
#58
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Tampa, Fl
Posts: 153
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
All this talk has got me thinking....The S03's weigh a ton (31FR 33RR) compared to stock(28FR-29RR). I think I'm going to sell the S03's and get some Toyo's T1-S. The Toyo's weigh in at 24FR and 26RR in 20's. That's less than stock tires. These weights are with a 245/35/20 and 275/30/20. Toyo doesn't make a 285/30 that I currently have so I might get the 245's in the front and put a 275 in the back. Of course this would put the overall diameter in the front over the 3%. I wonder if this will matter when it's not the drive wheel? By going with the Toyo's, I reduce the unsprung weight significantly and put the front wheels at 49lbs with the 20's compared to stock 51lbs. Stock in the rear is 53lbs and the new setup would yield 52.5lbs. This will allow me to get better performance while keeping the large wheels. As it is now, I'm at 55lbs per tire in the front and 59.5lbs per tire in the back with the S03's. That's a pretty big difference. Now if I can only find the weights for Nitto's.
Last edited by NOZ4U; 06-04-2004 at 01:46 PM.
#59
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Canada B.C.
Posts: 1,204
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by ALong
NOZ4U,
I see what you are now saying, yes the 20" wheels/tires are bigger than your stock wheels. As far as the look of the 17" they do actually look good on a lowered Z, take a look at pictures of the 350EVO and Performance Racing 350Z race cars, both have 17" front/rear wheel/tires.
GYZ, what suspension did you decide to get? Are you going with the Ohlins? I am still waiting for my JRZ's to arrive.....
NOZ4U,
I see what you are now saying, yes the 20" wheels/tires are bigger than your stock wheels. As far as the look of the 17" they do actually look good on a lowered Z, take a look at pictures of the 350EVO and Performance Racing 350Z race cars, both have 17" front/rear wheel/tires.
GYZ, what suspension did you decide to get? Are you going with the Ohlins? I am still waiting for my JRZ's to arrive.....
my local shop has ask zeal/endless to custome made few setz of coilovers.hopefully they'll try the prototype on my car, or i will rid in the car with the custome made coilover.
itz just too hard to decide if u didn't seat in the car !
#60
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: SeaTac
Posts: 151
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Have ordered a set of R1-RS4 (20" x 9" front & 20" x 11" rear) wheels and Michelin PS-2 (275-30-20 front & 295-25-20 rear) set to be installed by mid July. The weights on the 20" rims were less than the weight of the 18" stock wheels that came with the car (28lbs vs 25lbs although rears may be 30lbs). Not sure what the weight difference is on the tires. Anxious to see how they work with the Tein flex racing suspension that is on the car now.