2 Documented Engine Failures blaimed on the UR Crank Pulley
#101
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Atlanta
Posts: 575
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by LouZer
Paranoid posts running rampant. In cases like this, I almost think the forum is a bad thing. It causes paranoid thoughts in many Z drivers using UR pulleys without substantial proof. That being said, I have noticed a rattling since the install of the crank pulley. I cannot say for sure it is the pulley though, because Borla exhaust has also been reported on this forum as having vibration problems. Maybe the UR pulley is making my exhaust vibrate more, which will lead to my whole car falling apart...
GIVE ME A BREAK!
Paranoid posts running rampant. In cases like this, I almost think the forum is a bad thing. It causes paranoid thoughts in many Z drivers using UR pulleys without substantial proof. That being said, I have noticed a rattling since the install of the crank pulley. I cannot say for sure it is the pulley though, because Borla exhaust has also been reported on this forum as having vibration problems. Maybe the UR pulley is making my exhaust vibrate more, which will lead to my whole car falling apart...
GIVE ME A BREAK!
Ditto!
#103
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Wow, this is an ugly thread!
So let me ask two logical questions; first: are there any reliable reported cases of crank failure? Note: *CRANK* failure, not bearing failure, etc. Second: are there any reliable reported cases of belt derailment (belts hopping off the pulley)?
The VQ35 is a 60 degree V6; it is almost completely balanced through internals, with some residual vibration left to the engine mounts. You feel this residual vibration in the gearshift, which is a bit more active than in a straight six (BMW), or a flat six (Porsche). The front pulley on our VQ35's is *NOT* a harmonic balancer -- something used to achieve balance on 90 degree V8's of days gone by (before internal balance shafts).
Our VQ35 front pulley does incorporate a vibration damping ring; this damper is effective in reducing *TORSIONAL* vibration of the crankshaft.
Now, torsional vibration simply does not become a bending moment of the crank. Nor does it become a lateral nor longitudnal moment. And torsional vibration simply won't excite other modes of vibration, either.
What can happen if we remove the front pulley vibration damper and let this torsional vibration run amok? Will we encounter the dreaded "critical RPM's" and shake our engines to bits?
Well, if this was a problem, we would see two things happening:
1) cranks would fail from torsional vibration; we would see cranks shearing (typically at the first journal). Not bearing wear -- there's no bending moment -- just crank shear.
2) belts would hop off the pulley, as the belts would encounter a resonant frequency and jump off.
Thus, my two logical questions:
1) Are there any reliable reported cases of crank failure? Note: *CRANK* failure, not bearing failure, etc.
2) Are there any reliable reported cases of belt derailment (belts hopping off the pulley)?
(I've searched and searched for reports of these two sorts of failures and have yet to see any....)
-frank
Bone stock 2004ZR, but not for much longer
So let me ask two logical questions; first: are there any reliable reported cases of crank failure? Note: *CRANK* failure, not bearing failure, etc. Second: are there any reliable reported cases of belt derailment (belts hopping off the pulley)?
The VQ35 is a 60 degree V6; it is almost completely balanced through internals, with some residual vibration left to the engine mounts. You feel this residual vibration in the gearshift, which is a bit more active than in a straight six (BMW), or a flat six (Porsche). The front pulley on our VQ35's is *NOT* a harmonic balancer -- something used to achieve balance on 90 degree V8's of days gone by (before internal balance shafts).
Our VQ35 front pulley does incorporate a vibration damping ring; this damper is effective in reducing *TORSIONAL* vibration of the crankshaft.
Now, torsional vibration simply does not become a bending moment of the crank. Nor does it become a lateral nor longitudnal moment. And torsional vibration simply won't excite other modes of vibration, either.
What can happen if we remove the front pulley vibration damper and let this torsional vibration run amok? Will we encounter the dreaded "critical RPM's" and shake our engines to bits?
Well, if this was a problem, we would see two things happening:
1) cranks would fail from torsional vibration; we would see cranks shearing (typically at the first journal). Not bearing wear -- there's no bending moment -- just crank shear.
2) belts would hop off the pulley, as the belts would encounter a resonant frequency and jump off.
Thus, my two logical questions:
1) Are there any reliable reported cases of crank failure? Note: *CRANK* failure, not bearing failure, etc.
2) Are there any reliable reported cases of belt derailment (belts hopping off the pulley)?
(I've searched and searched for reports of these two sorts of failures and have yet to see any....)
-frank
Bone stock 2004ZR, but not for much longer
#104
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: columbia md.
Posts: 1,041
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by ct roadster
Wow, this is an ugly thread!
So let me ask two logical questions; first: are there any reliable reported cases of crank failure? Note: *CRANK* failure, not bearing failure, etc. Second: are there any reliable reported cases of belt derailment (belts hopping off the pulley)?
The VQ35 is a 60 degree V6; it is almost completely balanced through internals, with some residual vibration left to the engine mounts. You feel this residual vibration in the gearshift, which is a bit more active than in a straight six (BMW), or a flat six (Porsche). The front pulley on our VQ35's is *NOT* a harmonic balancer -- something used to achieve balance on 90 degree V8's of days gone by (before internal balance shafts).
Our VQ35 front pulley does incorporate a vibration damping ring; this damper is effective in reducing *TORSIONAL* vibration of the crankshaft.
Now, torsional vibration simply does not become a bending moment of the crank. Nor does it become a lateral nor longitudnal moment. And torsional vibration simply won't excite other modes of vibration, either.
What can happen if we remove the front pulley vibration damper and let this torsional vibration run amok? Will we encounter the dreaded "critical RPM's" and shake our engines to bits?
Well, if this was a problem, we would see two things happening:
1) cranks would fail from torsional vibration; we would see cranks shearing (typically at the first journal). Not bearing wear -- there's no bending moment -- just crank shear.
2) belts would hop off the pulley, as the belts would encounter a resonant frequency and jump off.
Thus, my two logical questions:
1) Are there any reliable reported cases of crank failure? Note: *CRANK* failure, not bearing failure, etc.
2) Are there any reliable reported cases of belt derailment (belts hopping off the pulley)?
(I've searched and searched for reports of these two sorts of failures and have yet to see any....)
-frank
Bone stock 2004ZR, but not for much longer
Wow, this is an ugly thread!
So let me ask two logical questions; first: are there any reliable reported cases of crank failure? Note: *CRANK* failure, not bearing failure, etc. Second: are there any reliable reported cases of belt derailment (belts hopping off the pulley)?
The VQ35 is a 60 degree V6; it is almost completely balanced through internals, with some residual vibration left to the engine mounts. You feel this residual vibration in the gearshift, which is a bit more active than in a straight six (BMW), or a flat six (Porsche). The front pulley on our VQ35's is *NOT* a harmonic balancer -- something used to achieve balance on 90 degree V8's of days gone by (before internal balance shafts).
Our VQ35 front pulley does incorporate a vibration damping ring; this damper is effective in reducing *TORSIONAL* vibration of the crankshaft.
Now, torsional vibration simply does not become a bending moment of the crank. Nor does it become a lateral nor longitudnal moment. And torsional vibration simply won't excite other modes of vibration, either.
What can happen if we remove the front pulley vibration damper and let this torsional vibration run amok? Will we encounter the dreaded "critical RPM's" and shake our engines to bits?
Well, if this was a problem, we would see two things happening:
1) cranks would fail from torsional vibration; we would see cranks shearing (typically at the first journal). Not bearing wear -- there's no bending moment -- just crank shear.
2) belts would hop off the pulley, as the belts would encounter a resonant frequency and jump off.
Thus, my two logical questions:
1) Are there any reliable reported cases of crank failure? Note: *CRANK* failure, not bearing failure, etc.
2) Are there any reliable reported cases of belt derailment (belts hopping off the pulley)?
(I've searched and searched for reports of these two sorts of failures and have yet to see any....)
-frank
Bone stock 2004ZR, but not for much longer
#105
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Cause of torsional vibration: Although I'm no Dinan fan (and doubly not so after reading the linked Z8 butchering story), he had it right in his "whitepaper"; torsional vibration is a simple consequence of the cylinders firing. Nothing you can do about it; it's a fact of life.
Why the damping ring in the pulley: my background is in some race engine work, not designing road engines, so take this with a grain of salt -- my understanding is that the damping ring in the vibration damper is to make the belts quiet and ensure that they don't hop off. Without damping out the vibration from the crank, the belts will make more noise (they will act like plucked strings at their resonant frequencies) and may hop off if you are unlucky enough to hit the right conditions. The belt arangement on the VQ35 in the Z has short enough free lengths that I sincerely doubt belt derailment is a problem in these engines.
Source of vibrations: the source of the torsional vibration is the crank; the vibration damper is isolating the accessories from vibrations in the crank, not the other way around.
-frank
Why the damping ring in the pulley: my background is in some race engine work, not designing road engines, so take this with a grain of salt -- my understanding is that the damping ring in the vibration damper is to make the belts quiet and ensure that they don't hop off. Without damping out the vibration from the crank, the belts will make more noise (they will act like plucked strings at their resonant frequencies) and may hop off if you are unlucky enough to hit the right conditions. The belt arangement on the VQ35 in the Z has short enough free lengths that I sincerely doubt belt derailment is a problem in these engines.
Source of vibrations: the source of the torsional vibration is the crank; the vibration damper is isolating the accessories from vibrations in the crank, not the other way around.
-frank
#106
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I should clarify one thing in my last post: when I wrote about the damping ring in the pulley being used to make the belts quiet, I mean this to apply to this particular situation, a 60-degree V6.
In other engines, particular longer engines like the BMW I6, the vibration damper is likely much more essential to preventing crank problems. V8's need both vibration damping *AND* a harmonic balancer; these are sometimes combined into a single unit, and othertimes the harmonic balance is provided by way of a balance shaft internal to the engine. I4's are similar to V8's in this regard.
It is the short overall length of the VQ35 that makes me believe that torsional vibration damping is not essential for these engines; further, if it were a problem, we would hear complaints of sheared crankshafts and derailed belts when running these lightweight undamped underdrive pulleys.
-frank
In other engines, particular longer engines like the BMW I6, the vibration damper is likely much more essential to preventing crank problems. V8's need both vibration damping *AND* a harmonic balancer; these are sometimes combined into a single unit, and othertimes the harmonic balance is provided by way of a balance shaft internal to the engine. I4's are similar to V8's in this regard.
It is the short overall length of the VQ35 that makes me believe that torsional vibration damping is not essential for these engines; further, if it were a problem, we would hear complaints of sheared crankshafts and derailed belts when running these lightweight undamped underdrive pulleys.
-frank
#107
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (564)
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Long Island, New York
Posts: 19,266
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Design time? NISMO doesn't design anything they just re-badge
frank - excellent post...refreshing to see someone who understands the simple physics of the engine!
Adam
#108
Sponsor
Performance Nissan
Performance Nissan
iTrader: (11)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: So-Cal - Ready to go?
Posts: 8,783
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
So meeting today with Jackson Stewart from Unitech & Stewart Racing, we not only talked about new product from the race team and new things the race cars will be sporting but also....
You guessed it....
UR Crank Pulleys...
Lets look at the stock pulley...
It does Not have a harmonic Dampener. It is NOT Balanced. It is made of a cast iron... Those of You who know, when metals are poured into a casting the different cooling speeds in certain sections of the cast as well as any inconsistency's in the material can cause density inconsistency's as well as weight differences.
Lets look at the UR Crank Pulley's...
They are FORGED out of a Solid piece of Billet Aluminum. You cant get much more balanced than that. The material's that these pulley's are forged out of is the same consistency and density tthought the material. If it is cut perfectly symmetrical (which they are in the forging process) then they are going to be perfectly balanced. So, actually running the stock pulley, even though it doesn't matter your stock pulley is NOT BALANCED! So if anything. The stock pulley will cause all the problems before the UR Pulley would.
Good reading on UR's web site at this link...
http://unorthodoxracing.com/faq_pulleys.html
oh yeah... all pulley colors are in stock again on www.mynismo.com![Smilie](https://my350z.com/forum/images/smilies/smile.gif)
You guessed it....
UR Crank Pulleys...
Lets look at the stock pulley...
It does Not have a harmonic Dampener. It is NOT Balanced. It is made of a cast iron... Those of You who know, when metals are poured into a casting the different cooling speeds in certain sections of the cast as well as any inconsistency's in the material can cause density inconsistency's as well as weight differences.
Lets look at the UR Crank Pulley's...
They are FORGED out of a Solid piece of Billet Aluminum. You cant get much more balanced than that. The material's that these pulley's are forged out of is the same consistency and density tthought the material. If it is cut perfectly symmetrical (which they are in the forging process) then they are going to be perfectly balanced. So, actually running the stock pulley, even though it doesn't matter your stock pulley is NOT BALANCED! So if anything. The stock pulley will cause all the problems before the UR Pulley would.
Good reading on UR's web site at this link...
http://unorthodoxracing.com/faq_pulleys.html
oh yeah... all pulley colors are in stock again on www.mynismo.com
![Smilie](https://my350z.com/forum/images/smilies/smile.gif)
![](http://unorthodoxracing.com/tuner_main.jpg)
#109
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: columbia md.
Posts: 1,041
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by ct roadster
I should clarify one thing in my last post: when I wrote about the damping ring in the pulley being used to make the belts quiet, I mean this to apply to this particular situation, a 60-degree V6.
In other engines, particular longer engines like the BMW I6, the vibration damper is likely much more essential to preventing crank problems. V8's need both vibration damping *AND* a harmonic balancer; these are sometimes combined into a single unit, and othertimes the harmonic balance is provided by way of a balance shaft internal to the engine. I4's are similar to V8's in this regard.
It is the short overall length of the VQ35 that makes me believe that torsional vibration damping is not essential for these engines; further, if it were a problem, we would hear complaints of sheared crankshafts and derailed belts when running these lightweight undamped underdrive pulleys.
-frank
I should clarify one thing in my last post: when I wrote about the damping ring in the pulley being used to make the belts quiet, I mean this to apply to this particular situation, a 60-degree V6.
In other engines, particular longer engines like the BMW I6, the vibration damper is likely much more essential to preventing crank problems. V8's need both vibration damping *AND* a harmonic balancer; these are sometimes combined into a single unit, and othertimes the harmonic balance is provided by way of a balance shaft internal to the engine. I4's are similar to V8's in this regard.
It is the short overall length of the VQ35 that makes me believe that torsional vibration damping is not essential for these engines; further, if it were a problem, we would hear complaints of sheared crankshafts and derailed belts when running these lightweight undamped underdrive pulleys.
-frank
#110
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
As to the first question, how long it would take for a problem to appear: it might surprise you, but this sort of problem is more serious at idle than at higher RPM. The reason is that torsional harmonics of the crankshaft and associated bits have a relatively low fundamental frequency (its a large-ish system), and directly exciting the fundamental frequency causes far more energy transfer into the resonance than by exciting the higher-order harmonics. So problems like this tend to show up very quickly!
As for your second question, about the ringing sound, I don't know. When belts slip and squeal, most of what you hear is actually coming from the belt, with the pulleys acting to some degree like a sounding board. Belts should not slip at all in operation (slip equals heat equals rapid wear, so definitely avoid it), so it's doubtful that the ring is there to prevent belt squeal from being overly loud. (In fact, it is in the manufacturer's best interest to make belt squeal really loud, so that you get it fixed ASAP.)
But a big round hunk of metal that is shaped somewhat like a bell -- the stock pulley -- may well be inclined to ring on its own, if its fundamental frequency gets excited. The bonded rubber ring would definitely put a stop to this aspect, so that is another potential explanation. Note that ringing is likely not going to be much of an issue with the aftermarket pulleys discussed here, as they are poked full of holes, swiss-cheese style. Further, if you compare the relative sizes of the belts versus the pulley, its pretty aparent that the belts have the larger area for emanating sound -- so I still think that the rubber ring would be more to keep the belts from singing. Then again, the free belt lengths on the VQ35 are so short that their fundamental frequencies are going to be very, very high (compare the lengths to that of a guitar -- different materials only change the timbre of the sound, not its fundamental pitch), and so the belts will likely only sing at high engine RPMs (when you have more high frequency vibration around to excite them).
And thus the above is what leads me to ask the two fundamental logic questions: 1) are there reliable reports of crank breakage related to these pulleys, and 2) are there reliable reports of belt derailment related to these pulleys? I've searched, and I've yet to read anything like that -- lots of (silly) supposition and the usual internet nonsense, but nothing logical.
-frank
As for your second question, about the ringing sound, I don't know. When belts slip and squeal, most of what you hear is actually coming from the belt, with the pulleys acting to some degree like a sounding board. Belts should not slip at all in operation (slip equals heat equals rapid wear, so definitely avoid it), so it's doubtful that the ring is there to prevent belt squeal from being overly loud. (In fact, it is in the manufacturer's best interest to make belt squeal really loud, so that you get it fixed ASAP.)
But a big round hunk of metal that is shaped somewhat like a bell -- the stock pulley -- may well be inclined to ring on its own, if its fundamental frequency gets excited. The bonded rubber ring would definitely put a stop to this aspect, so that is another potential explanation. Note that ringing is likely not going to be much of an issue with the aftermarket pulleys discussed here, as they are poked full of holes, swiss-cheese style. Further, if you compare the relative sizes of the belts versus the pulley, its pretty aparent that the belts have the larger area for emanating sound -- so I still think that the rubber ring would be more to keep the belts from singing. Then again, the free belt lengths on the VQ35 are so short that their fundamental frequencies are going to be very, very high (compare the lengths to that of a guitar -- different materials only change the timbre of the sound, not its fundamental pitch), and so the belts will likely only sing at high engine RPMs (when you have more high frequency vibration around to excite them).
And thus the above is what leads me to ask the two fundamental logic questions: 1) are there reliable reports of crank breakage related to these pulleys, and 2) are there reliable reports of belt derailment related to these pulleys? I've searched, and I've yet to read anything like that -- lots of (silly) supposition and the usual internet nonsense, but nothing logical.
-frank
#111
Registered User
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by Jason@Performance
So meeting today with Jackson Stewart from Unitech & Stewart Racing, we not only talked about new product from the race team and new things the race cars will be sporting but also....
You guessed it....
UR Crank Pulleys...
Lets look at the stock pulley...
It does Not have a harmonic Dampener. It is NOT Balanced. It is made of a cast iron... Those of You who know, when metals are poured into a casting the different cooling speeds in certain sections of the cast as well as any inconsistency's in the material can cause density inconsistency's as well as weight differences.
Lets look at the UR Crank Pulley's...
They are FORGED out of a Solid piece of Billet Aluminum. You cant get much more balanced than that. The material's that these pulley's are forged out of is the same consistency and density tthought the material. If it is cut perfectly symmetrical (which they are in the forging process) then they are going to be perfectly balanced. So, actually running the stock pulley, even though it doesn't matter your stock pulley is NOT BALANCED! So if anything. The stock pulley will cause all the problems before the UR Pulley would.
Good reading on UR's web site at this link...
http://unorthodoxracing.com/faq_pulleys.html
oh yeah... all pulley colors are in stock again on www.mynismo.com![Smilie](https://my350z.com/forum/images/smilies/smile.gif)
So meeting today with Jackson Stewart from Unitech & Stewart Racing, we not only talked about new product from the race team and new things the race cars will be sporting but also....
You guessed it....
UR Crank Pulleys...
Lets look at the stock pulley...
It does Not have a harmonic Dampener. It is NOT Balanced. It is made of a cast iron... Those of You who know, when metals are poured into a casting the different cooling speeds in certain sections of the cast as well as any inconsistency's in the material can cause density inconsistency's as well as weight differences.
Lets look at the UR Crank Pulley's...
They are FORGED out of a Solid piece of Billet Aluminum. You cant get much more balanced than that. The material's that these pulley's are forged out of is the same consistency and density tthought the material. If it is cut perfectly symmetrical (which they are in the forging process) then they are going to be perfectly balanced. So, actually running the stock pulley, even though it doesn't matter your stock pulley is NOT BALANCED! So if anything. The stock pulley will cause all the problems before the UR Pulley would.
Good reading on UR's web site at this link...
http://unorthodoxracing.com/faq_pulleys.html
oh yeah... all pulley colors are in stock again on www.mynismo.com
![Smilie](https://my350z.com/forum/images/smilies/smile.gif)
![](http://unorthodoxracing.com/tuner_main.jpg)
man wheres an own3d pic when you need it
![](https://my350z.com/forum/images/smilies/icon18.gif)
#112
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (564)
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Long Island, New York
Posts: 19,266
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Jason - the forging process is not what balances the UR pullies...its the CNC;ing they udergo (how the metal becomes "cut" into a pulley), followed by the shaving they do to make sure each one is balanced.
The onyl purpose the rubber ring in the stock pulley serves is noise reduction - that's it.
The onyl purpose the rubber ring in the stock pulley serves is noise reduction - that's it.
#116
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Del Rio, Texas
Posts: 790
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://my350z.com/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by Jason@Performance
oh yeah... all pulley colors are in stock again on www.mynismo.com![Smilie](https://my350z.com/forum/images/smilies/smile.gif)
oh yeah... all pulley colors are in stock again on www.mynismo.com
![Smilie](https://my350z.com/forum/images/smilies/smile.gif)