Is something wrong with my car or is this normal
#21
Originally posted by julian
question for y'all that are complaining about the ride: didn't you guys test drive the car before buying it?
question for y'all that are complaining about the ride: didn't you guys test drive the car before buying it?
Some of the people complaining had preordered their cars, so they didn't have a chance to test drive.
#22
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Bloomingdale, IL
Posts: 64
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Right on the test drive hindsight. I shoulda thrashed it more and taken it out for a 30 mile drive. Don't think my sales guy woulda been ok with that. Just got off the phone with him. Joe Cross at Gerald Nissan. Great guy, great dealer. He is getting me contact info for Nissan Regional and will talk to the GM at Gerald. I'm gonna try the weight in the back tomorrow. Got about 80 miles of driving to test it.
#23
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Alamo, CA
Posts: 694
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Julian: If you spend much time on my350z.com you will soon notice that there are a wide variety of strongly expressed opinions. It took me a while to get used to it because I absolutely love my new 350, and it seemed many were absolutely hating the car. This has definitely not been my experience.
When I complain about the tires, I actually do not have a gripe with Nissan. I guess that my gripe should be directed at Bridgestone for calling these tires high performance and charging a high price for them. I have experience with the Bridgestone (Pole position) tires and really loved them on my Datsun 510. I can hardly wait to replace the tires with poles.
Anyone asks me about the Z, I would sing only praises to my car. If anyone asks me if they should buy the car....everyone has their own preference.
btw I grew up in Ann Arbor--junior high, high school, college, med school--still have many fond feelings although this time of year the fond feelings are a little colder.
When I complain about the tires, I actually do not have a gripe with Nissan. I guess that my gripe should be directed at Bridgestone for calling these tires high performance and charging a high price for them. I have experience with the Bridgestone (Pole position) tires and really loved them on my Datsun 510. I can hardly wait to replace the tires with poles.
Anyone asks me about the Z, I would sing only praises to my car. If anyone asks me if they should buy the car....everyone has their own preference.
btw I grew up in Ann Arbor--junior high, high school, college, med school--still have many fond feelings although this time of year the fond feelings are a little colder.
Last edited by jackwhale; 02-27-2003 at 08:08 PM.
#24
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: so cal
Posts: 502
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I guess a bunch of us are not alone in thinking the bouncyness of the car or rythmic occillation which occurs on cupped or irregular roads should not be something one has to endure on nissan's flagship sports car! I think im going to call nissan and bring this up has anyone organised a formal group complaint to see if nissan cant recall and setup our cars with the proper spring and dampning rates? Or who is starting a petition ? The bouncyness only when it happens makes you think for an otherwise outstanding car.
#25
Registered User
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Tampa, Fl
Posts: 255
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by julian
question for y'all that are complaining about the ride: didn't you guys test drive the car before buying it?
I drove one briefly for 15 minutes (not long enough if I were looking to purchase a car) and could tell the car was extremely stiff. mytalon-Definitely soft?! I disagree. You want a sports car, you got a sports car. But I do agree that it shouldn't be bouncing like that. My limited experience tells me that if your car is bouncing you need lower spring rates and/or higher damping. I didn't think it was that bad when I drove it, but then again the road wasn't that bumpy either.
If nissan put all season tires on the Z, then people would complain about not having grippy tires. What do you guys expect of 17" low profile tires? You're talking about a manufacturer that makes cars for the entire US region. There's no way they can separate tire choice at the plant based on geography. Leave it as a dealer installed option.
question for y'all that are complaining about the ride: didn't you guys test drive the car before buying it?
I drove one briefly for 15 minutes (not long enough if I were looking to purchase a car) and could tell the car was extremely stiff. mytalon-Definitely soft?! I disagree. You want a sports car, you got a sports car. But I do agree that it shouldn't be bouncing like that. My limited experience tells me that if your car is bouncing you need lower spring rates and/or higher damping. I didn't think it was that bad when I drove it, but then again the road wasn't that bumpy either.
If nissan put all season tires on the Z, then people would complain about not having grippy tires. What do you guys expect of 17" low profile tires? You're talking about a manufacturer that makes cars for the entire US region. There's no way they can separate tire choice at the plant based on geography. Leave it as a dealer installed option.
#26
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: redondo beach, ca
Posts: 712
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
talon - yup, i don't have a z and have an opinion. Like I said I drove one for 15 minutes and I couldn't detect any appreciable roll on the short stretch of windy roads, but public roads aren't the ideal place to evaluate a car. I'm trying to get some time in the track model that's sitting outside our office, hopefully I'll be able to finangle it today. I got to drive the 333hp M3 that's out there for a little while and that was very grin-inducing. The beemers i've driven in the past always seem to have pretty good bump and impact absorption given the car's handling, but this m3 seemed a little stiff in the back. I wasn't complaining when I was on the handling course but I also wouldn't want to drive one on Michigan roads. Just like I wouldn't want to drive a Z on Michigan roads. I'd feel bad beating the cars to death.
jwhale - I moved here from california for my job and so far it's been alright. But high's in the 20's definitely suck. Another reason I would think twice about getting another RWD car. datsun 510 eh?... very nice.
jwhale - I moved here from california for my job and so far it's been alright. But high's in the 20's definitely suck. Another reason I would think twice about getting another RWD car. datsun 510 eh?... very nice.
#31
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 23,397
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm not flaming you guys, but I gotta say that I don't undertand what you guys expect to have done about this. I personally don't have an opinion either way on the "bouncing" matter, as I've only had my car for about 700 miles now and it really hasn't bugged me.
I can't help but feel that NO auto manufacturer would bother with buying and installing new suspensions for its cars already sold unless its a safety issue. Recalls only happen when there is a necessary safety measure. I can't imagine Nissan determining that this is anything more than personal preference and arguing that you didn't have to buy the car if you didn't like it. Now, I understand that the pre-order people wouldn't have had a chance to test drive the car, but they also made the choice to by the car before any hope of a test drive. Please understand that I'm using these points to illustrate a possible point of view from Nissan, not necessarily myself.
I can't help but feel that NO auto manufacturer would bother with buying and installing new suspensions for its cars already sold unless its a safety issue. Recalls only happen when there is a necessary safety measure. I can't imagine Nissan determining that this is anything more than personal preference and arguing that you didn't have to buy the car if you didn't like it. Now, I understand that the pre-order people wouldn't have had a chance to test drive the car, but they also made the choice to by the car before any hope of a test drive. Please understand that I'm using these points to illustrate a possible point of view from Nissan, not necessarily myself.
#33
Charter Member #13
Join Date: May 2002
Location: California
Posts: 745
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The is one of those debates where people say the same things over again and don't seem to be listening to each other.
Whenever someone brings up the bounciness problem, there are all these "it's a sports car so it's supposed to be stiff" replies. Please, people, read carefully.
People are NOT complaining that the suspension gives a stiff ride. We understand that sports cars have a stiff ride in order to provide good handling and flat cornering. Sports car people do not mind a stiff ride. That is not the problem here!
The problem is the way the car bounces up and down on some road surfaces. This is NOT a necessary result of a stiff ride. Many cars with very stiff suspensions and harsh rides can ride these same roads without going bounce-bounce-bounce and shaking you around like you're riding on a paint-can shaker machine.
Now please, before someone replies with "you shouldn't have bought a sports car if you wanted a smooth ride", please read the above over again, carefully.
It's possible that many people have never noticed this and think it's fine, which I can understand because it is highly dependent on road surface. I can drive for many miles and it feels great, but when I hit a certain section of road, everything starts jumping up and down like mad. And don't blame the road -- none of the other cars are doing it.
Whenever someone brings up the bounciness problem, there are all these "it's a sports car so it's supposed to be stiff" replies. Please, people, read carefully.
People are NOT complaining that the suspension gives a stiff ride. We understand that sports cars have a stiff ride in order to provide good handling and flat cornering. Sports car people do not mind a stiff ride. That is not the problem here!
The problem is the way the car bounces up and down on some road surfaces. This is NOT a necessary result of a stiff ride. Many cars with very stiff suspensions and harsh rides can ride these same roads without going bounce-bounce-bounce and shaking you around like you're riding on a paint-can shaker machine.
Now please, before someone replies with "you shouldn't have bought a sports car if you wanted a smooth ride", please read the above over again, carefully.
It's possible that many people have never noticed this and think it's fine, which I can understand because it is highly dependent on road surface. I can drive for many miles and it feels great, but when I hit a certain section of road, everything starts jumping up and down like mad. And don't blame the road -- none of the other cars are doing it.
#35
New Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: South Carolina
Posts: 215
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You guys with bouncing problems should definately be talking to your dealer and Nissan. My 350 does not do anything like what you people are talking about. Not one little bit. Completely stock suspension and tires, no bounce. Maybe there are some defective shocks out there that never got filled with hudraulic fluid??? Agreed, the car should not do this. You have a warranty, use it.
#37
Originally posted by fullylowdd
Maybe the members complaining about the ride should have considered a G35... If you dont want a sports car ride, then dont buy a sports car.
Maybe the members complaining about the ride should have considered a G35... If you dont want a sports car ride, then dont buy a sports car.
2. G35 is not a 350Z. If someone wants a 350Z bodystyle, that person doesn't get it with a G35. Yes, the cars are somewhat similar, but a G35 has "luxury car" look while G35 has "sports car" look.
3. The interiors are different, I personally prefer the 350Z over G35.
#38
Originally posted by 350z4steve
good man dr_gallup
thats what im gonna do is call nissan if its a problem they will fix it if its normal then they wont ..what to lose right?
good man dr_gallup
thats what im gonna do is call nissan if its a problem they will fix it if its normal then they wont ..what to lose right?
Nissan is going to want to have the car road tested.
#39
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Vancouver BC
Posts: 8
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
that kind of bouncing you all are talkin about is down to the valving in the shocks not matching the spring rates.
On my 944 turbo I run bilstien full race shocks revalved to work with #350 Eibach coils , it is pretty stiff on the street, but there is no oscillation at all, it is rock solid. And there shouldn't be with correct valving to match the springs.
The shocks are too weak to control the springs and that is why your car bounces like that.
On my 944 turbo I run bilstien full race shocks revalved to work with #350 Eibach coils , it is pretty stiff on the street, but there is no oscillation at all, it is rock solid. And there shouldn't be with correct valving to match the springs.
The shocks are too weak to control the springs and that is why your car bounces like that.
Last edited by k27; 02-28-2003 at 03:34 PM.
#40
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Alamo, CA
Posts: 694
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I agree that we must be talking about different things. On certain concrete sections of freeway during my commute, the 350 has a thump/bumping feel. I have driven that section in many cars and they all do it to a certain degree. Everyone I know notices that section of road, no matter what car they are driving. There are short sections of different pavement where everything smooths right out. I have blamed the tires which I thought 'grabbed' the furrows in the concrete. (now I don't feel so confident about my analysis of the situation)
and I now can hear you <z350z> when you say that you are noticing something which is very abnormal, and no car should have thumping/bumping to that degree. Clearly some cars have the problem and others don't. I'm not a great mechanic but there must be a reason: such as problems with what has been mentioned:
1. tires
2. allignment
3. shocks
4. spring rate
5. incompatible shock/spring combo
6. etc.
and I now can hear you <z350z> when you say that you are noticing something which is very abnormal, and no car should have thumping/bumping to that degree. Clearly some cars have the problem and others don't. I'm not a great mechanic but there must be a reason: such as problems with what has been mentioned:
1. tires
2. allignment
3. shocks
4. spring rate
5. incompatible shock/spring combo
6. etc.