#1 looks more like the real thing... the black 'lines' on the other options look a bit strange.

Nice renderings, by the way.

C.

 

3 - I have an 07 PPW and its the closest in the color

 

#1 is the best, but you need to take the whiteness of #3 and put it on #1 and you will achieve perfection.

#1 looks a bit yellowish to me while #3's white captures PPW better.

but #1 looks more real to me.

 

My artistic opinion:

#1 shows the cleanest design, other than the wheels. All others have way to thick a stroke which destroys the flow.

You should learn the mesh tool for more accurate renderings.

All in all they look suitable for game usage.

 

1

 

You might want to drop the car a bit.

 

What year are you trying to model after? I see 06 headlights and front grill. But i see 03-05 rims.... with brembro's.

 

I like 1.

 

1

 

Definately number O-N-E #1.

The rest look cartoonish. yuck

 

1

 

+ 1!! And drop it a little should be about right. The other do don't look that real. Kinda comic booky.

 

1

 

A strong #1 feeling here.

 

2.

 

2

 

1 looks the best to me because the outline of the headlights in 2 and 3 are way too dark. But t1 looks a little bland when compared to the shading used in 2 and 3. I think if you used the headlights from 1 with the shading in 2 it'd look better (imo).

 

2

 

2

 

OnE