I had the brake shop paint the rotors with a rust-protective paint, and am actually quite pleased with the result. I think it looks better than the orange at least, and the shop didn't charge me. When I buy my next set of brakes I will definitely take this under consideration. Thanks everyone.

 

That looks great!

 

Thanks! I think it looks pretty good too. I am glad I decided to go with the silver, because they originally told me to get black paint. I think it turned out pretty good, and you can't really tell that it is different on the rear wheels. I think the next time I get a set of brakes I am going to have the calipers painted as well. Now if I could just figure out how to get those damn water spots out of my rims....