View Poll Results: Which short antenna gets the best reception?
S2000
58
64.44%
Perrin
9
10.00%
IS3000
3
3.33%
Other (please list)
20
22.22%
Voters: 90. You may not vote on this poll
Antenna Poll... which WORKS the best?
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
From: New York
Antenna Poll... which WORKS the best?
I've searched all over, and it's either a S2k antenna, or a Perrin, with the random IS300 antenna thrown in the mix. But which one WORKS the best (reception wise)?
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
From: New York
Originally Posted by Fluid1
How many people do you think have actually had one of each of those to be able to compare?? 
Not too bright, are ya.
Not too bright, are ya.It's a poll, if 90 people voted for the S2k, and 10 voted for the Perrin I have my answer.
Originally Posted by MrSteak
I don't expect everyone to have had both...
It's a poll, if 90 people voted for the S2k, and 10 voted for the Perrin I have my answer.
It's a poll, if 90 people voted for the S2k, and 10 voted for the Perrin I have my answer.
Originally Posted by abui01
Yeah, antennas are like penises, smaller they are, the less functional.
Trending Topics
Originally Posted by MrSteak
I don't expect everyone to have had both...
It's a poll, if 90 people voted for the S2k, and 10 voted for the Perrin I have my answer.
It's a poll, if 90 people voted for the S2k, and 10 voted for the Perrin I have my answer.
I am willing to be this is exactly what the result of your poll will be since the s2k is the most popular (but not necessarily the best).
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
From: New York
Originally Posted by Silkk
I see what Fluid is saying even though there was no need to be so harsh. If 90 people vote for the s2k and 10 for the perrin that doesn't necessarily mean its better; it means that 90 people have the s2k and think it works good enough and 10 people have the perrin and think it works good enough. It's doubtful that any of those 100 people had both and can say which "works better".
I am willing to be this is exactly what the result of your poll will be since the s2k is the most popular (but not necessarily the best).
I am willing to be this is exactly what the result of your poll will be since the s2k is the most popular (but not necessarily the best).
I'm not gonna put together a research team of scientists in a lab somewhere comparing antennas. I don't expect the results to be definitive by any means, but if the majority of the people prefer one over the other, that’s good enough for me. (Especially since it's just a $20 part.)
Originally Posted by MrSteak
Do you have the 4" Perrin? (Otherwise what antenna do you have?)
Registered User
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 1,349
Likes: 0
From: Ohio
Originally Posted by MrSteak
Heh... like I said, it's just a poll.
I'm not gonna put together a research team of scientists in a lab somewhere comparing antennas. I don't expect the results to be definitive by any means, but if the majority of the people prefer one over the other, that’s good enough for me. (Especially since it's just a $20 part.)
I'm not gonna put together a research team of scientists in a lab somewhere comparing antennas. I don't expect the results to be definitive by any means, but if the majority of the people prefer one over the other, that’s good enough for me. (Especially since it's just a $20 part.)