On Forged Rods and Pistons...
#21
for street purposes...off-boost performance is important to most people. The beauty of our motor is the deep torque curve,,,,even at very low RPM.
I dont want a gutless motor below 3000rpm. I think 9:0-9.5 would be my ideal.
350zteve, I agree with you for the most part...that forged internals wont save you from detonation. However, LC pistons will resist detonation, and if detonation does occur, they will hold up much better. Forged pistons tend to have better rings, pins, and of course we change the rods, so the entire rotating assumblying is significantly strengthened.
Also, I dont want people to think that 1 sec of detonation will blow up a motor. Detonation, or pinging, occurs on the power stroke, AFTER the spark has fired. Engine can tolerate a good amount of pinging for many many minutes. I have a company car (Pontiac Grand Prix 2002), and the thing pings like crazy when I floor it up the onramps. I kinda also do it for fun...since its not my engine. My point is that lots of cars detonate or ping, and it doesnt result in the immediate destruction of the engine.
The real danger...and most people don't realize this...is not detonation, but pre-ignition. Pre-ignition occurs on the compression stroke, BEFORE the piston reaches TDC, and BEFORE the spark fires. So essentially, the fuel/air mixture is spontaneously combusting while the piston is still traveling upward. Run that image through your head...and you can see that the piston is traveling upward at TREMENDOUS velocity, and then boom....the piston is hit with a force that is trying to drive it down. The result is usually immediate and catstrophic failure of the piston, rings, rods, or rod bears. This is ugly.
Pre-iginition can destroy a motor in 1 sec...no joke.....but detonation or pinging takes some time. Of course, the wild-card here is that detonation can eventually result in pre-ignition.
So the moral of the story is.....when you hear a ping....let off the gas immediatly.
Did everyone enjoy the bedtime story?
Sweet dreams everyone!
I dont want a gutless motor below 3000rpm. I think 9:0-9.5 would be my ideal.
350zteve, I agree with you for the most part...that forged internals wont save you from detonation. However, LC pistons will resist detonation, and if detonation does occur, they will hold up much better. Forged pistons tend to have better rings, pins, and of course we change the rods, so the entire rotating assumblying is significantly strengthened.
Also, I dont want people to think that 1 sec of detonation will blow up a motor. Detonation, or pinging, occurs on the power stroke, AFTER the spark has fired. Engine can tolerate a good amount of pinging for many many minutes. I have a company car (Pontiac Grand Prix 2002), and the thing pings like crazy when I floor it up the onramps. I kinda also do it for fun...since its not my engine. My point is that lots of cars detonate or ping, and it doesnt result in the immediate destruction of the engine.
The real danger...and most people don't realize this...is not detonation, but pre-ignition. Pre-ignition occurs on the compression stroke, BEFORE the piston reaches TDC, and BEFORE the spark fires. So essentially, the fuel/air mixture is spontaneously combusting while the piston is still traveling upward. Run that image through your head...and you can see that the piston is traveling upward at TREMENDOUS velocity, and then boom....the piston is hit with a force that is trying to drive it down. The result is usually immediate and catstrophic failure of the piston, rings, rods, or rod bears. This is ugly.
Pre-iginition can destroy a motor in 1 sec...no joke.....but detonation or pinging takes some time. Of course, the wild-card here is that detonation can eventually result in pre-ignition.
So the moral of the story is.....when you hear a ping....let off the gas immediatly.
Did everyone enjoy the bedtime story?
Sweet dreams everyone!
#22
If you use a TT kit with stock compression and then rebuild the engine with lower compression, the car would lose its zippy torquey feeling when off boost cruising. Of course that's the trade with TT vs. N/A but i don't believe everybody is after power on boost and doesn't care what happens off boost. At the end of the day most ppl who opt for TT are after porsche 911 twin turbolike performance+ for less half the price.
I'm not sure if greddy or PE release information on what comp ratio is the best to use with their kit. But that'd be great to know. Ppl who buy Greddy, PE or APS tt kit will rebuild their engines sooner or later so it'd be good to know what CR is the best for each kit.
I'm not sure if greddy or PE release information on what comp ratio is the best to use with their kit. But that'd be great to know. Ppl who buy Greddy, PE or APS tt kit will rebuild their engines sooner or later so it'd be good to know what CR is the best for each kit.
#24
Z1, a lot of people, inlcuding myself, whan to maintain significant torque below 3000rpm. In my opinion, the car on the street...especially on surface streets is rolling between 2300-3000rpm, so I would like to maintain that zippy feeling down low.
Hey...so WTF...nobody liked my bedtime story?? I endured hotel dial-up to write that thing up.
Hey...so WTF...nobody liked my bedtime story?? I endured hotel dial-up to write that thing up.
#26
Originally posted by slay2k
Yo gq, yeah your story was mad l33t.
Anyway, do you get boost under 3k ? I don't think I do...
Yo gq, yeah your story was mad l33t.
Anyway, do you get boost under 3k ? I don't think I do...
Another possibility is a boost leak somewhere.
#27
No, I do get boost in the higher gears... no gauges yet so can't tell how much, but I can hear violet wastegate noises under 3k if i shift 4th to 5th gear...
But like in 1st and somewhat in 2nd, it kicks in around 3k+, that normal ?
But like in 1st and somewhat in 2nd, it kicks in around 3k+, that normal ?
#28
Hey Slay2K, I would recommend you get a boost guage so that you can see what your boost is at. Also have you dyno'd to see if your a/f is in line? Just somthing to think about. Sorry if you already done this I haven't kept up much with the FI section.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post