Hey,

I have an 07 and everytime I am in first gear and drive until 2 1/2 rpm then let go of the gas and let it roll for a sec or two.....When you step on the clutch does it make a clunking noise? Like from the tranny? I got the recall done and the whole tranny replace already. Tell me that this is not normal.....???

 

I dont get a POP noise...but when im in 1st and i let go off the gas..i get this whine all the way till i push the clutch in

 

Yeah I get a whine noise too but my tranny make like a loud pop noise. It feels like the tranny about to drop

 

Mine makes a similar noise (assuming I'm picturing your description correctly), although I'd describe my tranny noise as more of a clunk than a pop. Usually it's worse when it's cold and the car isn't warmed up. Thats just the sound you can expect from our clumsy tranny when you disengage the clutch at a high engine speed. I wouldn't worry about it.

 

It just feel soo wrong to hear a tranny do that. I use to have an RSX and it never gave me any problem and I had it til it was 130K miles on it.

 

i have the same problem...i've heard it's a normal thing for our cars...but you learn to drive without having to deal with that...just don't stay in first too long without having the gas on it before you change gears

 

i only hear the clunk when i first start driving. after a minute or two the clunking sound disappears completely.

 

it's normal, we all have loud clutches. My 07 whines in 1st and clunks same as yours. I wouldn't sweat it.

 

Thanks guys

 

Sorry guys unless you drive a semi- it shouldnt sound like one. Ill copy and paste what Ive been though with my 07 tranny recently. Hope it helps-dont give up.



1-29-08
Me-what were your cars symptoms and what did they replace? Most Importantly WHICH dealer. Im in San Antonio as well and have complained about the whining/growling noise in idle and the whining noise in 1st/2nd for the longest time.Each time classified as normal same with stuck pedal.


5-19-08
Me-local jax dealer ordered parts today- appt about a week away. I mentioned that my clutch seems to be slipping at WOT and I still have an annoying whine in 1st gear. They didnt test drive as appt isnt for another week but mentioned that if clutch is out thats a non covered wear item. WTF car is barely a year old- Ive gotten 20k miles obviously 70-80% highway miles and clutch is on its way out! Every BMW I have ever owned 10+ - I always get 100k+ miles out of stock clutches. Even on my boosted e30 on light boost 8 psi 240whp vs stock 155whp I got 30k miles on a already used stock clutch with countless track runs before I finally upgraded.

I cant believe nissan parts are that cheaply made.BTW Ive been complaining of the tranny noise since second week of ownership and keep being told its normal to sound like a semi in 1st gear

While I doubt it I hope all these issues go away while doing slave install--- all under warranty.



5-31-08 Update: Me-Got my car back just a while ago. They replaced slave cylinder and it SEEMS as if the slipping clutch feeling is gone.They confirmed clutch still had plenty of life left.Most importantly they recognized that my transmission noise is not normal in first gear.They couldnt shift it with ease into 2nd during spirited driving or really low speeds. its like if something is "stuck" or it has an artificial gate feeling.Im glad someone finally listened to me and they are replacing the tranny next week.Thats the good news. The bad news is that during these 2 days in the shop I strolled over to test drive a used 2007.5 corvette and I havnt stopped thinking about it.Think Im gonna take the plunge in spring 09 and get a new vette instead of the next Z.


6-9-08 Newest update! Me-I got my tansmission and clutch assembly replaced today.All the issues are gone! I can finally shift into second and all gears with ease. Tranny noises are gone-new tranny duh.I now enjoy spirited driving again! time to hit the track again.

 

You just listed a whole bunch of issues he doesn't have.

 

i have noticed that every once in a blue moon. doesn't seem to hurt the car...........for now. only heard it maybe 3 times, but i know the sound you mean.

jim

 

I got the whole tranny replace and it was good but then a couple of months later my clutch seem to engage higher and while in first gear it always make a clunk noise when the clutch is depress when your off the gas

 

I just did a search for clutch noise, and found this thread. The tranny in first gear & sometimes second sounds clunky. ~~ 05 Base with 16,000 miles. If I am in 1st or 2nd, let off the gas, depress the clutch, I hear some clunking.

 

It clunks. When you are at a stop light turn down the radio release the clutch and sit there for a sec. Press the clutch and gear it. The Z will clunk. It has since 03.

 

Are you mistaken? The recall work does not replace the entire transmission. It replaces the clutch fluid and replaces the slave cylinder.

 

Anwser to all this, dealer told me that it clunks when riding in 1st and then drepressing the clutch becuase of the preasure the clutch put on the gear and when you depress it, it will make that noise but it's ok....

 

yeah the clunking sound is typical of our cars.

the whine is coming from the engine, and i absolutely love the sound of it.

 

I have an 08 and from day one its been making that clunk sound. I thought it was normal. I get that whining sound too. i guess since alot of us have it maybe its normal?

 

I'm not mistaken...... I got the recall done... and it was still making the noise so Nissan REPLACE my whole tranny and FIX

And yes the whinning noise is normal and the clunking noise is too.. Don't worry guys.... It clunks cuzz all the preasure is on the gear and when you depress the clutch it will clunk