OEM LSD should I?
#24
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Maryland
Posts: 317
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I got a Quaife 2 way and took the Z to VIR. Performance was great! I drift the car every now and then, much more predictable than an open diff. Also, if you are on a track, the diff actually helps to turn the car as the axel locks and the outer wheel 'pushes' your car into the turn. Pretty awesome, lots of fun. I got it a year ago and had it professionally installed, and used Red Line fluid which is probably why it hasn't turned into a $1200 paperweight.
And BTW, the Quaife is not a 2-way differential. If one of the wheels loses all traction, for example if it lifts completely off the ground, it will act like an open differential.
As for the guy wondering about the VLSD, they all progressively get worse over time and fail eventually.
Limited-slip differential on Wikipedia:
"Viscous LSDs are less efficient than mechanical types, that is, they "lose" some power. In particular, any sustained load which overheats the silicone results in sudden permanent loss of the differential effect. They do have the virtue of failing gracefully, reverting to semi-open differential behavior. Typically a visco-differential that has covered 60,000 miles (97,000 km) or more will be functioning largely as an open differential; this is a known weakness of the original Mazda MX-5 (a.k.a. Miata) sports car. The silicone oil is factory sealed in a separate chamber from the gear oil surrounding the rest of the differential. This is not serviceable; when the differential's behavior deteriorates, the VLSD center must be replaced."
Again, do you want to take that chance, or do you want to do it right the first time?
BTW, someone mentioned that the newest VLSD would be from a 2008 Z. Aren't the pumpkins in the 350Z and 370Z the same?
#26
350Z-holic
iTrader: (60)
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: San Antonio/I miss DFW, TX
Posts: 11,204
Likes: 0
Received 28 Likes
on
19 Posts
Definitely not saying the VLSD is great by any means...but is there any real evidence proving the VLSD sucks so bad? I just find it odd that Nissan would have wasted their time for it to just "go bad" after hardly any miles have been put on it.
I do intend to upgrade mine at some point in the future when I decide to swap gears if I stay N/A...but it sure does do a damn better job than an open diff...
I do intend to upgrade mine at some point in the future when I decide to swap gears if I stay N/A...but it sure does do a damn better job than an open diff...
Nissan designed a VLSD that the "Masses" will love - think about it, there are ton of Z's out there and only a niche market are the "enthusiast".....
I know tons of co-workers, friends that simply daily drive and don't change their own oil, garage kept and sell it later cause they want something newer...
ie, Nissan gave the Z a quiet, friendly vlsd that meets the minimum requirements....
that being said - Nissan hit the market just fine! did they fall short for enthusiast, i would say ya just a bit....
Now to answer your question more directly:
Ex#1:
-you think your vlsd does a dammn better job than an open diff - I would say 'yes, i agree'
--- as in, if your driving home and a sudden medium rain starts,...... your driving carefully and responsibly but then you take a turn in the rain and the rear "slips".....the vlsd diff didn't let you completely get sideways - then - the VDC sensors that are mounted on the diff output shafts catch the variance in rotational speeds on each side of the diff and it actives - which turns on the abs cross manipulation braking / cuts power the engine and saves you from completely sliding. yey nissan vdc system....
---in that above situation - think about it, whats the resistance the vlsd is counter-reacting???
its reacting very very little resistance, i mean your traction gave way, the vlsd shear'd ......
the rain is lifting the oils from the ground and putting them on the surface of the water creating a laminar sheet of thin slippery lubricant on the road...
the thick viscosity of the vlsd unit inside the rear diff can hold the two sides of the diff together UNTIL it reached that turn you just lost it on...ie, a failure....
--meaning, - my point -- is that it takes very little for the vlsd "when new" to shear......
Remember- the above example is an example of the vlsd failing.....ie, the viscous fluid in the vlsd shearing and the car loosing it.
Ex#2:
---- where does the vlsd shine - (again when new):
when your driving striaght down a road in that same rain and you hit some puddles in the road...you hit a puddle on the right hand, passenger side and the car stays going straight - you will see the vdc / slip light flash for a quick moment, but the car STAYS going straight! meaning the Left hand drivers side wheel had more traction, the vlsd kept the RH side spinning at its same speed UNTIL it hit that puddle, at that moment the RH side spun faster, due to the loss of traction and the VDC system reacted - agian from the sensors catching that delta/change in rotation...it was so fast that it kept YOU safe and the car driving straight and forward.....
- testing -
This is how, stop at grocery store, buy a gallon of water...
Then, find a asphalt road with no street curb- like a local city park road or parking lot or something, back the car up at an angle to where the front wheels and the drivers side wheel is on the asphalt but only the passenger side rear wheel is on the nice green grass.....
Test 1:
-get back in the car and drive fwd and see how you get out of the grass and back onto the asphalt....take note of what lights and be aware of how the car reacts, feel the rear end catch and remember that feeling..
- do it again and a new spot a few feet away from the first spot - well, because the grass is most likely flattened and fugged up....remember good testing is duplicating all aspects of the environment of the test...
Test 2:
reposition the car again same as test 1, but this time get out, pour water all over the grass in front of the passenger side tire, ie the path the rear passenger side tire will travel and now try and get out...
- take extra gallons of water and try it again if you want..
remember notice the difference, watch the lights on your dash and FEEL how the car reacts...
ALSO --- have your friends go with you cause you may need help pushing your car if you get stuck....lol...
My point - i have and felt and KNOW when a vlsd is working and dead and acting like an open diff, been there done that.....what im proposing is for you to test for your self and realize what me and others are talking about when we comment on the the VLSD "limited" capabilities....
-J
Last edited by JasonZ-YA; 07-22-2013 at 09:45 AM.
#28
350Z-holic
iTrader: (60)
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: San Antonio/I miss DFW, TX
Posts: 11,204
Likes: 0
Received 28 Likes
on
19 Posts
^ thx...
I rock a loud a *** Nismo LSD in my car........im use to its harsh noise, clunk and popping.....but it's the "sound of performance" every time i hear it......
too bad im a **** poor driver...wah wah...
-J
I rock a loud a *** Nismo LSD in my car........im use to its harsh noise, clunk and popping.....but it's the "sound of performance" every time i hear it......
too bad im a **** poor driver...wah wah...
-J
#32
350Z-holic
iTrader: (60)
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: San Antonio/I miss DFW, TX
Posts: 11,204
Likes: 0
Received 28 Likes
on
19 Posts
^ that's a great answer....
if your really that worried and want lsd thats not loud, clunky, etc then really about your only option is the quaife helical geared lsd....most clutch plate friction locking lsd will be noisy and usually operate like a on/off switch.......
os giken would be your next - but due to cost, i wouldnt unless you know you plan to utilize it....u can set the giken up to your needs..adjust the spring tension on it for street driving an make it quiet..
-J
if your really that worried and want lsd thats not loud, clunky, etc then really about your only option is the quaife helical geared lsd....most clutch plate friction locking lsd will be noisy and usually operate like a on/off switch.......
os giken would be your next - but due to cost, i wouldnt unless you know you plan to utilize it....u can set the giken up to your needs..adjust the spring tension on it for street driving an make it quiet..
-J
Last edited by JasonZ-YA; 07-22-2013 at 07:24 PM.
#33
New Member
iTrader: (1)
I guess I'm a little weird though. I love all the sounds of my Z. Flywheel chatter, stupid loud exhaust, whine from my poly tranny bushing...I'm all about function, but to really do it right you gotta pay to play sometimes. If I spend the $$ on a serious diff, that sumbish better lock up hardcore
#34
Super Moderator
MY350Z.COM
MY350Z.COM
iTrader: (8)
I guess I'm a little weird though. I love all the sounds of my Z. Flywheel chatter, stupid loud exhaust, whine from my poly tranny bushing...I'm all about function, but to really do it right you gotta pay to play sometimes. If I spend the $$ on a serious diff, that sumbish better lock up hardcore
#35
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Maryland
Posts: 317
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As one forum member put it, he likes the "Predator" sound.
Note, this is without the fluid combination I mentioned above. Mine only gets this loud now when I need to change it. Oh, and it really only happens in slow turns like in the video.
Last edited by NightShade; 07-23-2013 at 12:15 PM.
#37
New Member
iTrader: (3)
NISMO GT PRO LSD
As one forum member put it, he likes the "Predator" sound.
Note, this is without the fluid combination I mentioned above. Mine only gets this loud now when I need to change it. Oh, and it really only happens in slow turns like in the video.
As one forum member put it, he likes the "Predator" sound.
Note, this is without the fluid combination I mentioned above. Mine only gets this loud now when I need to change it. Oh, and it really only happens in slow turns like in the video.
#40
350Z-holic
iTrader: (60)
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: San Antonio/I miss DFW, TX
Posts: 11,204
Likes: 0
Received 28 Likes
on
19 Posts
NO, but when you are racing, drifting etc, you want to turn off vdc obviously as you dont want the vdc interacting and getting in the way..
See post 28 and post 29 here:
https://my350z.com/forum/6274342-post28.html
-J
See post 28 and post 29 here:
https://my350z.com/forum/6274342-post28.html
-J
Last edited by JasonZ-YA; 07-25-2013 at 06:15 PM.