Misfire diagnosis
#1
Registered User
Thread Starter
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Misfire diagnosis
Hey all,
Seems like my car is heavily missing.
It all started 2 nights ago. I decided to give it a hit and all of sudden, the car just held back, as if traction control came on. After that, i could feel it missing slightly under acceleration. It went away after 20 minutes of limping it back home. Confirmed it wasn't misfiring when i gave it WOT with no issues.
Next morning, drove to work. 1hr trip, started missing badly just 2 minutes away from my work. It was idling badly. If rev comes down to quickly, it will stall. Black smokes everywhere when i tried to accelerate but i couldn't even get past 3k rpm.
When it was time to go home, i started it up, it started rough but i was able to rev a bit more better. Then it would clear up and it was back to normal again. I was able to drive it home with no issues
This morning, i said to myself, if i started up and its having issues, i will start troubleshooting. I was hoping it was a bad batch of fuel and all i needed was to burn the crap bits off. Wishful thinking. 30 minutes into the trip, it started missing again. This time, i couldn't limp it home, won't go past 1k rpm. Had to tow it home.
TL;DR
Car started misfiring intermittently, now its here to stay.
Things i have done:
-Leaving it idling (roughly) i started to disconnect coilpacks one by one. Had no affect to the idle
-Pulled plugs, all 6 were black (this may have been the reason why unplugging the coilpacks didn't do anything)
My next course of action:
-Buying 6 new plugs, and disconnecting the coilpack so i can at least know which cylinder is missing as i have no CEL
Possible issues:
-Coilpacks
-Injectors
-Bad batch of fuel (still have half a tank left)
-Issue with injector harness
Current mods that's related to this issue:
-DW 600CC (recently replaced as i had misfiring issue 10,000km ago and a faulty injector was the cause. The misfiring i had before wasn't as bad as this one though)
-HKS V-pro 3.2 (no idea why its not showing up any codes. Do v-pro's mask OEM cels?)
-Running no MAFs, just IAT and MAP
-Exedy clutch/flywheel (recently replaced <1500km)
-Walbro 255
Im open to any other suggestions or troubleshooting advice
Cheers
Seems like my car is heavily missing.
It all started 2 nights ago. I decided to give it a hit and all of sudden, the car just held back, as if traction control came on. After that, i could feel it missing slightly under acceleration. It went away after 20 minutes of limping it back home. Confirmed it wasn't misfiring when i gave it WOT with no issues.
Next morning, drove to work. 1hr trip, started missing badly just 2 minutes away from my work. It was idling badly. If rev comes down to quickly, it will stall. Black smokes everywhere when i tried to accelerate but i couldn't even get past 3k rpm.
When it was time to go home, i started it up, it started rough but i was able to rev a bit more better. Then it would clear up and it was back to normal again. I was able to drive it home with no issues
This morning, i said to myself, if i started up and its having issues, i will start troubleshooting. I was hoping it was a bad batch of fuel and all i needed was to burn the crap bits off. Wishful thinking. 30 minutes into the trip, it started missing again. This time, i couldn't limp it home, won't go past 1k rpm. Had to tow it home.
TL;DR
Car started misfiring intermittently, now its here to stay.
Things i have done:
-Leaving it idling (roughly) i started to disconnect coilpacks one by one. Had no affect to the idle
-Pulled plugs, all 6 were black (this may have been the reason why unplugging the coilpacks didn't do anything)
My next course of action:
-Buying 6 new plugs, and disconnecting the coilpack so i can at least know which cylinder is missing as i have no CEL
Possible issues:
-Coilpacks
-Injectors
-Bad batch of fuel (still have half a tank left)
-Issue with injector harness
Current mods that's related to this issue:
-DW 600CC (recently replaced as i had misfiring issue 10,000km ago and a faulty injector was the cause. The misfiring i had before wasn't as bad as this one though)
-HKS V-pro 3.2 (no idea why its not showing up any codes. Do v-pro's mask OEM cels?)
-Running no MAFs, just IAT and MAP
-Exedy clutch/flywheel (recently replaced <1500km)
-Walbro 255
Im open to any other suggestions or troubleshooting advice
Cheers
Last edited by rorii; 08-16-2013 at 12:50 AM.
#3
Registered User
Thread Starter
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Update:
Bought new plugs. Installed them and it was idling fine. Started to unplug a coilpack at a time. All 6 had an effect on the idle.
So i am unable to determine which cylinder the misfire is happening. I haven't had a chance to drive it yet but when i do, i will probably take it easy and won't hit boost until this tank of fuel has depleted
Bought new plugs. Installed them and it was idling fine. Started to unplug a coilpack at a time. All 6 had an effect on the idle.
So i am unable to determine which cylinder the misfire is happening. I haven't had a chance to drive it yet but when i do, i will probably take it easy and won't hit boost until this tank of fuel has depleted
#6
New Member
iTrader: (3)
It seems unless the missfire is 100% of the time constant the ecu won't throw a code. It took 2 weeks of random missfires to get which one was bad. By that time I had taken all the plugs out and measured the gapping, they had all gone from 1.1 to frakking 1.8-2.3!!!! I also found oil from the spark plug holes since the seals were shot
Trending Topics
#8
Registered User
Thread Starter
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Took it for a drive, ok for 30 minutes. Then the last turn into my street, I decided to gave it 40% throttle and it started missing again but managed to come back to normal.
I seriously hope it's not the injectors. It's bad enough that you have to buy 6 at a time when you only needed one. But at least i still got 5 used good ones from my last injector ordeal that i can troubleshoot with.
Due to no help with a CEL to locate the cylinder, I will be replacing all coil packs with a new one. Decided on Splitfires. Don't seem to have the luxury of buying cheaper ones in Australia. Either I go with oEM, buy cheap ones from eBay and wait 2-3weeks for delivery, or buy the Splitfires for cheaper than OEM
From there, i will start diving deeper through the manifold and start looking at injectors and harnesses.
Should there be any else i can check? PCV valve? Don't think its a vacuum leak either as it idles fine and i've checked the plumbing.
Will update the thread as I go
I seriously hope it's not the injectors. It's bad enough that you have to buy 6 at a time when you only needed one. But at least i still got 5 used good ones from my last injector ordeal that i can troubleshoot with.
Due to no help with a CEL to locate the cylinder, I will be replacing all coil packs with a new one. Decided on Splitfires. Don't seem to have the luxury of buying cheaper ones in Australia. Either I go with oEM, buy cheap ones from eBay and wait 2-3weeks for delivery, or buy the Splitfires for cheaper than OEM
From there, i will start diving deeper through the manifold and start looking at injectors and harnesses.
Should there be any else i can check? PCV valve? Don't think its a vacuum leak either as it idles fine and i've checked the plumbing.
Will update the thread as I go
Last edited by rorii; 08-17-2013 at 03:00 PM.
#10
New Member
iTrader: (3)
Took it for a drive, ok for 30 minutes. Then the last turn into my street, I decided to gave it 40% throttle and it started missing again but managed to come back to normal.
I seriously hope it's not the injectors. It's bad enough that you have to buy 6 at a time when you only needed one. But at least i still got 5 used good ones from my last injector ordeal that i can troubleshoot with.
Due to no help with a CEL to locate the cylinder, I will be replacing all coil packs with a new one. Decided on Splitfires. Don't seem to have the luxury of buying cheaper ones in Australia. Either I go with oEM, buy cheap ones from eBay and wait 2-3weeks for delivery, or buy the Splitfires for cheaper than OEM
From there, i will start diving deeper through the manifold and start looking at injectors and harnesses.
Should there be any else i can check? PCV valve? Don't think its a vacuum leak either as it idles fine and i've checked the plumbing.
Will update the thread as I go
I seriously hope it's not the injectors. It's bad enough that you have to buy 6 at a time when you only needed one. But at least i still got 5 used good ones from my last injector ordeal that i can troubleshoot with.
Due to no help with a CEL to locate the cylinder, I will be replacing all coil packs with a new one. Decided on Splitfires. Don't seem to have the luxury of buying cheaper ones in Australia. Either I go with oEM, buy cheap ones from eBay and wait 2-3weeks for delivery, or buy the Splitfires for cheaper than OEM
From there, i will start diving deeper through the manifold and start looking at injectors and harnesses.
Should there be any else i can check? PCV valve? Don't think its a vacuum leak either as it idles fine and i've checked the plumbing.
Will update the thread as I go
#12
Banned
How long has the car been running the piggy back?
Can you give us some feedback and info on the background of that so we can check into it.
Can you give us some feedback and info on the background of that so we can check into it.
Last edited by 9K RACING; 08-22-2013 at 12:45 PM.
#13
Registered User
Thread Starter
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Update: replaced all coilpacks with splitfires. Started up fine, gave it a few WOT's and didn't hesitate or sputter. Thought the issue was fixed.
On the way to work this morning, driving it very casually, shifted it up to 2 and heard a big pop from the exhaust and car started to sputter. It sputter for probably 20 seconds before it slowly eased itself back to normal.
So the issue is still there GRRR. Will limp it back home and pray that i don't foul all my plugs by then.
I've had the F-con for a bit over 2 yrs now. Haven't had any issues until early this year with a similar misfiring issue that was solved by replacing a faulty coilpack and injectors (unsure if it was both on the same cylinder, a shop was working on it)
My next step is to pull apart the plenum and look for bad wiring to injectors. With no CEL, its just a matter of replacing parts and hoping for the best. Its turning out to be a very expensive and frustrating exercise
On the way to work this morning, driving it very casually, shifted it up to 2 and heard a big pop from the exhaust and car started to sputter. It sputter for probably 20 seconds before it slowly eased itself back to normal.
So the issue is still there GRRR. Will limp it back home and pray that i don't foul all my plugs by then.
I've had the F-con for a bit over 2 yrs now. Haven't had any issues until early this year with a similar misfiring issue that was solved by replacing a faulty coilpack and injectors (unsure if it was both on the same cylinder, a shop was working on it)
My next step is to pull apart the plenum and look for bad wiring to injectors. With no CEL, its just a matter of replacing parts and hoping for the best. Its turning out to be a very expensive and frustrating exercise
#14
Registered User
iTrader: (2)
Update: replaced all coilpacks with splitfires. Started up fine, gave it a few WOT's and didn't hesitate or sputter. Thought the issue was fixed.
On the way to work this morning, driving it very casually, shifted it up to 2 and heard a big pop from the exhaust and car started to sputter. It sputter for probably 20 seconds before it slowly eased itself back to normal.
So the issue is still there GRRR. Will limp it back home and pray that i don't foul all my plugs by then.
I've had the F-con for a bit over 2 yrs now. Haven't had any issues until early this year with a similar misfiring issue that was solved by replacing a faulty coilpack and injectors (unsure if it was both on the same cylinder, a shop was working on it)
My next step is to pull apart the plenum and look for bad wiring to injectors. With no CEL, its just a matter of replacing parts and hoping for the best. Its turning out to be a very expensive and frustrating exercise
On the way to work this morning, driving it very casually, shifted it up to 2 and heard a big pop from the exhaust and car started to sputter. It sputter for probably 20 seconds before it slowly eased itself back to normal.
So the issue is still there GRRR. Will limp it back home and pray that i don't foul all my plugs by then.
I've had the F-con for a bit over 2 yrs now. Haven't had any issues until early this year with a similar misfiring issue that was solved by replacing a faulty coilpack and injectors (unsure if it was both on the same cylinder, a shop was working on it)
My next step is to pull apart the plenum and look for bad wiring to injectors. With no CEL, its just a matter of replacing parts and hoping for the best. Its turning out to be a very expensive and frustrating exercise
Did you change your flywheel or anything else with an important sensor recently?
I really doubt it's your injector wiring. Can you pull up any data logs on the HKS? And what does your afr look like when you have a misfire....? Does the car jump from rich to lean to rich? or?
I do remember on my buddies car we had issues with the PFC just going crazy on the timing at idle (ranged from 17 to 27 deg!). We fixed that by fixing the vacuum leak, but still no cigar.
#15
Registered User
Thread Starter
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Will have to ask my tuner regarding data log. With no wideband installed on the car, I'm afraid the info, if any, will be of use.
I can smell fuel when it sputters and my spark plugs fouls up.
I've got 5 working injectors that I will put in. The 6th one that I won't replace will be assumed the working one. If it misfire again, I will replace the 6th one with the ones I pulled out. If it still misses, then I have ruled out injectors being the issues and start looking elsewhere.
Let me know if that's how I should go about with this.
Cheers
I can smell fuel when it sputters and my spark plugs fouls up.
I've got 5 working injectors that I will put in. The 6th one that I won't replace will be assumed the working one. If it misfire again, I will replace the 6th one with the ones I pulled out. If it still misses, then I have ruled out injectors being the issues and start looking elsewhere.
Let me know if that's how I should go about with this.
Cheers
#16
Registered User
Thread Starter
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My car starts up OK
#17
Registered User
iTrader: (8)
Faulty crankshaft position sensor can cause car to stall in neutral/clutch in too I believe. It's possible the engine could crank over, and run, but subsequently stall. There was a recall for this very reason on some early Z's with bad crankshaft position sensors wiring.
Last edited by mcarther101; 08-25-2013 at 11:52 AM.
#18
Registered User
iTrader: (2)
A trick we used to tell if the rb26 car was having ignition issues vs maf etc issues: force the ecu into limp mode. If the misfire is still persistent then it is ignition/fuel mechanically related. I'm not sure if the limp mode on the vq35 is alpha N tuning or not but if it is, it may help you narrow it down.
Last edited by Resmarted; 08-25-2013 at 01:38 PM.
#19
Registered User
Thread Starter
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Update: had a chance to work on the car and removed all injectors. Got it flow tested and found one of them had an erratic spray pattern. But flow is pretty consistent on all 6.
Is the spray pattern enough to cause the misfire?
Is the spray pattern enough to cause the misfire?