View Poll Results: Going from 2in exhaust,to a 3in, longtube header, 2.25 Ypipe,on 8000K ITB Rev make?
1-5WHP
10
12.66%
5-10WHP
17
21.52%
10-15WHP
13
16.46%
15-20WHP
20
25.32%
20-30WHP
19
24.05%
Voters: 79. You may not vote on this poll
Kevin's VQ35DE NA Build Epilogue..
#81
I hope you are joking. Unless you have FI...properly tuned exhaust is far better than just throwing the biggest pipe that fits. If that was the case, we all will have open dumps.
Case in point, last week we observed the new Camaro SS gaining approximately 15whp from a exhaust, then they added HFC...which lost about half the gain then they added resonated pipe which lost all the hp they gained and went back to stock.
Case in point, last week we observed the new Camaro SS gaining approximately 15whp from a exhaust, then they added HFC...which lost about half the gain then they added resonated pipe which lost all the hp they gained and went back to stock.
#82
Not true, the power band and average power will suffer with an exhaust with no back pressure. Low end torque will be 0 and the powerband might only start to climb past 4-5krpm, possibly later. Wouldn't be anything more than a track car that needs to be driven at 4k rpm or higher at any one time.
I did not lose any low end torque/power when I went to a catless 3" exhaust system..
#84
Registered User
iTrader: (3)
Having minimal backpressure is not about throwing on the biggest pipe, it's about maximizing exhaust velocity with the least restrictions The more restrictions you have, the more back pressure you have. People tend to think back pressure is all in the pipe diameter..
#85
#86
I have no idea.. ask the people who claim that your exhaust needs backpressure..
#87
Heres a thread from this site that proves backpressure for our engines is no good.
https://my350z.com/forum/intake-exha...k-for-n-a.html
https://my350z.com/forum/intake-exha...k-for-n-a.html
#88
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: WC
Posts: 40
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
in the ideal world with a correctly designed header and exhaust system you will not need any backpressure. Most of the problems with almost every exhaust system out there is in the collector where the gasses merge. If you have a crappy collector, a formed one, or none at all, Then when the exhaust gasses flow from the primary tube into the collector, they dispurse and have no smooth transition causing a lot of turbulance... Mostly from the size transition being to great... I.E. (3) 1 3/4 tubes into a 3" formed collector. Not only do the gasses lose velocity, but they also lose their refractive wave pulse and pressure waves which effect scavenging and more...
Bottom line, a header/exhaust system that "needs" back pressure to work, and or make power, is a poorly designed system.
Now this is not to say that if you take this exhaust setup from a 2.25" exhaust to a 3" that he will not lose low end power due to the header design, but the power gains up top would be there if there is power loss due to reversion, or cam timing compensation due to reversion which will retard cam timing too fast and lose power, ( could lose power, depends on every setup).
Every header/exhaust size (the tube diameter them selves) is based mainly on the displacement of the engine and the VE of the motor ( the actual amount of air being "pumped" through it) and then how high of an RPM does the motor run... I.E. generally, speaking at higher RPMs the exhaust gas velocity will get too high on "x" size pipe and cause a restriction, so you will need to increase the pipe size for best higher RPM power.
Bottom line, a header/exhaust system that "needs" back pressure to work, and or make power, is a poorly designed system.
Now this is not to say that if you take this exhaust setup from a 2.25" exhaust to a 3" that he will not lose low end power due to the header design, but the power gains up top would be there if there is power loss due to reversion, or cam timing compensation due to reversion which will retard cam timing too fast and lose power, ( could lose power, depends on every setup).
Every header/exhaust size (the tube diameter them selves) is based mainly on the displacement of the engine and the VE of the motor ( the actual amount of air being "pumped" through it) and then how high of an RPM does the motor run... I.E. generally, speaking at higher RPMs the exhaust gas velocity will get too high on "x" size pipe and cause a restriction, so you will need to increase the pipe size for best higher RPM power.
#89
Registered User
iTrader: (3)
Heres a thread from this site that proves backpressure for our engines is no good.
https://my350z.com/forum/intake-exha...k-for-n-a.html
https://my350z.com/forum/intake-exha...k-for-n-a.html
What I gather from the thread is no different in concept except the terms being used, while "incorrect" the term back pressure has been equated by having a balance of restriction inside the exhaust system, thus creating the scavenging effect, by having completely eliminate said restrictions it would equate to having no back pressure and a open dump exhaust, which you said would be the best scenario, and this wasn't the case and definitely isn't what you should deduce from the thread.
What I gathered is this, your header to Y pipe choice in the upstream side of your exhaust is far more important than your downstream, that being said, yes even if you eliminate the exhaust completely after the Y pipe, there is minimal difference in power/torque, however the upstream pipe diameter is still crucial in creating proper "restrictions" previously termed "back pressure" to create more power via scavenging than simply going with the largest pipe.
going back on topic, the OP isn't changing an ordinary exhaust, he's also going with long tube headers, which would most definitely change how the overall system affects his power output whether positive or negative is yet to be seen.
Last edited by Ivory; 06-11-2010 at 08:17 AM.
#90
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: South Florida
Posts: 255
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Whoever voted the 20-30WHP I like! haha. Nice showing, if I get a solid 10-15whp over the entire powerband I'd be very happy. Who knows though, given how terrible my exhaust was haha.
#92
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: South Florida
Posts: 255
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#93
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: South Florida
Posts: 255
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Freshened up the car with a couple new parts.
Engine back in its place though and ready to go.
Now our exhaust is all being completely custom made. I'm getting what I paid for back then for a "custom" setup which was just a bunch of crap bolted together that would fit. Nothing custom at all. This time not getting ripped off. This one truly is custom and to exact specification of what I wanted! I'm very excited to be turning it on soon and bringing her back to TPS to retune. Expect some good gains with what we freshened the motor up with =).
Exhaust shots!
That is right, check out the Borla tip, looks top notch and sleeper which is exactly what I'm going for. Just a clean look.
All the welding is top notch. Will take more pictures later, running 2 Magnaflow mufflers so she'll sound nice and smooth.
Engine back in its place though and ready to go.
Now our exhaust is all being completely custom made. I'm getting what I paid for back then for a "custom" setup which was just a bunch of crap bolted together that would fit. Nothing custom at all. This time not getting ripped off. This one truly is custom and to exact specification of what I wanted! I'm very excited to be turning it on soon and bringing her back to TPS to retune. Expect some good gains with what we freshened the motor up with =).
Exhaust shots!
That is right, check out the Borla tip, looks top notch and sleeper which is exactly what I'm going for. Just a clean look.
All the welding is top notch. Will take more pictures later, running 2 Magnaflow mufflers so she'll sound nice and smooth.
Last edited by kgkeen101; 07-06-2010 at 06:38 PM.
#96
fully custom? did you ditch those ebay longish/short headers?
Last edited by thepat; 07-08-2010 at 01:41 PM. Reason: because i wanted to