AT vs MT
Originally Posted by amf813
I say buy a MT....Look at how many AT drivers try to disguise their shift **** by adding a boot....I think they regret buying the AT and are tired of being criticized for the decision.
MT all the way.
MT all the way.
I bought the car for myself and not somebody else... I love my car and anybody who doesn't like it, can keep watching from their civic...
Originally Posted by rmesola
dunno who you're talking about.. but I haven't seen anybody disguise any boot.... and I sure haven't.... it's my car, it's a z, when peopole see it they say "nice car" I've never heard any auto comments.... I don't drag and I don't race, maybe that's the difference...
I bought the car for myself and not somebody else... I love my car and anybody who doesn't like it, can keep watching from their civic...
I bought the car for myself and not somebody else... I love my car and anybody who doesn't like it, can keep watching from their civic...
if you get an AT the car drives you.
if you get a MT you drive the car. i have an MT and use it as my daily driver and have no qualms about it. i dont see how much more unpractical it is to get an MT over an AT. if i want practicality i would have bought a 4 seater car like a prius or something.
yeah, ideally, one would get a car that he/she likes and not care about what other thought. although, i think it would be kinda annoying explaining why you would buy a two seater sports car because it was more practical.
if you get a MT you drive the car. i have an MT and use it as my daily driver and have no qualms about it. i dont see how much more unpractical it is to get an MT over an AT. if i want practicality i would have bought a 4 seater car like a prius or something.
yeah, ideally, one would get a car that he/she likes and not care about what other thought. although, i think it would be kinda annoying explaining why you would buy a two seater sports car because it was more practical.
lol @ woochang, word. I'm gonna get a MT for sure, it was just too much fun in the test drive (didnt even get it over 5k rpm or 4th gear either lol..) Thanks for all the help, beginning of March I will be in the club!
Originally Posted by wooochang
yeah, ideally, one would get a car that he/she likes and not care about what other thought. although, i think it would be kinda annoying explaining why you would buy a two seater sports car because it was more practical.
For "practical" I have my other car, an X5 3.0 TD, for fun the Z
my buddy & I both bought are cars almost together... he got a 6speed rx8, i got a 6 speed Z. we have average commutes every morning on the dreaded 405.
as of today, he wishes he had gotten an automatic cause he hates bumper-to-bumper shifting, me, i wouldn't dream of even considering an automatic.
basically its different strokes for different folks.. depends on whether its your daily driver and whether u like stick shifts to begin with.
get someone who has a stick and drive it for a day before u get a stick & then realize you want an automatic...
as of today, he wishes he had gotten an automatic cause he hates bumper-to-bumper shifting, me, i wouldn't dream of even considering an automatic.
basically its different strokes for different folks.. depends on whether its your daily driver and whether u like stick shifts to begin with.
get someone who has a stick and drive it for a day before u get a stick & then realize you want an automatic...
Originally Posted by roast
The day I'm too old and decrepit to operate a manual transmission, someone shoot me please. 

The first time I have to drive a manual in Los Angeles traffic I would hope you would do the same for me.
A 37 page post on replaced transmissions?
I hope not on the autos.
Mentioned in this post:
https://my350z.com/forum/maintenance-and-repair/169370-any-high-mileage-6spd-350z-s-w-o-trans-problems.html
I hope not on the autos.
Mentioned in this post:
https://my350z.com/forum/maintenance-and-repair/169370-any-high-mileage-6spd-350z-s-w-o-trans-problems.html
Originally Posted by Paul350Z
A 37 page post on replaced transmissions?
I hope not on the autos.
Mentioned in this post:
https://my350z.com/forum/showthread.php?t=169370
I hope not on the autos.
Mentioned in this post:
https://my350z.com/forum/showthread.php?t=169370
'nuff said.
Originally Posted by dscheers
It isn't more practical, but the Z only comes in 2 seats (the G35 is NOT a Z
). The Z does come with an 5AT ...
For "practical" I have my other car, an X5 3.0 TD, for fun the Z
For "practical" I have my other car, an X5 3.0 TD, for fun the Z
Originally Posted by jvanquish
if you want to choose which gear you are in ...
manual...
if you like someone to make the choice for you in life...
automatic...
if you like more...
manual...
if you like less...
automatic...
manual...
if you like someone to make the choice for you in life...
automatic...
if you like more...
manual...
if you like less...
automatic...
Originally Posted by slackjaw
Wonder if I can get the Enzo (or any other Ferrari) w/ an automatic?? C'mon, no sports car should be auto-trans. This shouldn't even a consideration. My 2 cents.
Originally Posted by amf813
I say buy a MT....Look at how many AT drivers try to disguise their shift **** by adding a boot....I think they regret buying the AT and are tired of being criticized for the decision.
MT all the way.
MT all the way.
we just want to trying tell him that there is very little differece between
mt and at
but people who's driving manual kept pulling down the auto people
Originally Posted by slackjaw
Wonder if I can get the Enzo (or any other Ferrari) w/ an automatic?? C'mon, no sports car should be auto-trans. This shouldn't even a consideration. My 2 cents.
all those expensive ferrari and lambo are come with auto tranny these day
Everyone on this board subscribes to the Doctorine that "If it is more expensive it is better" and "You get what you pay for". By that logic, the 5AT is more expensive and therefore Better.
End of Discussion.
End of Discussion.
Originally Posted by sq40
Everyone on this board subscribes to the Doctorine that "If it is more expensive it is better" and "You get what you pay for". By that logic, the 5AT is more expensive and therefore Better.
End of Discussion.
End of Discussion.
sure the the civic with diamond spinners would cost more, but it should would be a pain in the *** explaining why you got a civic with diamond spinners on it.
similar to explaining why youd get a Z with AT.
theres nothing wrong with AT. the only 2 problems i see (if it can be considered problems) is
1) people saying how youre retarded for gettin an AT sportscar
2) coming from driving AT all my life, driving MT just feels more like im driving the car instead of riding in it.
thats basically the only difference
convenience (AT) vs not being ridiculed and having more control of your car
Originally Posted by wooochang
sure the the civic with diamond spinners would cost more, but it should would be a pain in the *** explaining why you got a civic with diamond spinners on it.
similar to explaining why youd get a Z with AT.
theres nothing wrong with AT. the only 2 problems i see (if it can be considered problems) is
1) people saying how youre retarded for gettin an AT sportscar
2) coming from driving AT all my life, driving MT just feels more like im driving the car instead of riding in it.
thats basically the only difference
convenience (AT) vs not being ridiculed and having more control of your car
Really though..
i have mixed emotions about my 5AT. When I was working out the deal on the car, the I could only Find 1 Super Black ZR, It was a 5AT. I didn't really want the Auto since I like driving a stick, but the Wife pressured me a bit and the Auto "Wasn't that bad" IMO..
I have grown to like the Auto just for the convenience of throwing it in drive and being done with it, especially if im tired. BUT, I really do miss having the stick when I'm wanting to get on it.. The manual Mode is fun, but the trow is way too long with the 8 inch "*****" of a shifter. So I might do the MOMO short thow swap out.. Maybe that will satisfy my desire to shift a bit.
Last edited by sq40; Feb 6, 2006 at 12:28 PM.







