Synthetic Oil Issue..a big deal
Mobil 1 always skirts around the actually question. When asking "Is mobile 1 100% synethic motor oil", they always give some convoluted proprietary answer, rather than saying we use x% ester, and x% PAO..or group IV or whatever.
I am certainly no expert on motor oils base types....wish I had more time for that. But we exclusively use Motul 100% synthetic lubricants. You could cook food with their 300V Competition oil.
Or use it as a salad dressing...the stuff even smells like fine wine.
I am certainly no expert on motor oils base types....wish I had more time for that. But we exclusively use Motul 100% synthetic lubricants. You could cook food with their 300V Competition oil.
Or use it as a salad dressing...the stuff even smells like fine wine.
again, thank you Sharif. I have seen oil analysis tests done, and researched these topics, not relying on the manufacturer 'sales propoganda' FAQ section... if you could call it a 'answered question' section since they really don't answer the FAQ's at all... lol.
Originally Posted by Zincognito
Sharif: how much for some Motul oil???
FYI, I used to run Mobil 1, and I've taken apart of couple of engines that used the oil as well. Honestly, there was no meaningful bearing or journal wear that I could detect. All modern oils provide outstanding levels of protection. But on really expensive engines, I don't want the best oil...I want the best of THE BEST.
I use to run Mobil 1 but then i started noticing oil consumption almost right away so i switched to Royal Purple.
Speaking of oil consumption, a guy here, RUZRIOUS had the exact same problem some time ago. He could hear his pistons pinging and when he when he checked it, their was no oil whatsoever in it. Yeah i know that it shouldnt do that but thats just careless.You should check it atleast twice a week.
Thanks Sharif
Speaking of oil consumption, a guy here, RUZRIOUS had the exact same problem some time ago. He could hear his pistons pinging and when he when he checked it, their was no oil whatsoever in it. Yeah i know that it shouldnt do that but thats just careless.You should check it atleast twice a week.
Thanks Sharif
Here is a list of group III and group IV oils. As you can see most Amsoils and Mobil 1 are group IV. POA base stock.
COMMON 5W-30 SYNTHETIC OILS
Product Name Base Viscosity Index Pour Point °C (°F) Volatility % Weight Loss Four Ball Wear TBN Service Life Suggested Cost (Qt) Cost/10 Miles
Para. 1 Para. 3
Amsoil
XL-7500 (XLF) Group III/
Hydrocracked 196 -51 (-60) 8.8% 0.35 0.38 10.1 7500 Miles/
6 Months $5.20 4.0 cents
Amsoil (ASL) Group IV/
POA 182 -51 (-60) 6.9% 0.35 0.40 >11.0 25,000 Miles/1 Year $5.85 2.6 cents
Mobil 1 Group IV/
PAO 168 -48 (-54) 9.2% 0.35 0.60 8.5 Mfg. Rec. $4.78 3.7 cents
Pennzoil Synthetic Group III/
Hydrocracked 161 -48 (-54) 5.7% 0.40 0.60 10.0 Mfg. Rec. $4.49 3.6 cents
Valvoline SynPower Group III/
Hydrocracked 164 -44 (-47) 13.1% 0.35 0.55 8.9 Mfg. Rec. $4.48 3.6 cents
Castrol Syntec Group III/
Hydrocracked 147 -39 (-38) 10.0% 0.40 0.61 10.0 Mfg. Rec. $4.47 3.6 cents
Quaker State Full Synthetic Group III/
Hydrocracked 183 -46 (-51) 10.2% 0.35 0.55 7.7 Mfg. Rec. $3.97 3.2 cents
COMMON 10W-30 SYNTHETIC OILS
Product Name Base Viscosity Index Volatility % Weight Loss Four Ball Wear TBN Service Life Suggested Cost (Qt) Cost/10 Miles
Amsoil
XL-7500 (XLT) Group III/
Hydrocracked 163 4.7% 0.38 10.2 7500 Miles/
6 Months $5.20 4.0 cents
Amsoil (ATM) Group IV/
POA 167 6.6% 0.35 >12.2 25,000 Miles/1 Year $5.85 2.6 cents
Mobil 1 Group IV/
PAO 147 11.1% 0.35 8.5 5000 Miles $4.78 5.4 cents
Castrol Group III/
Hydrocracked 159 5.47% 6.81 5000 Miles $4.48 5.1 cents
Shell Group III/
Hydrocracked 140 5000 Miles $4.97 5.6 cents
Pennzoil Group III/
Hydrocracked 150 9.5% 0.65 7.18 5000 Miles $4.49 5.1 cents
Valvoline Group III/
Hydrocracked 140 8.3% 0.40 6.85 5000 Miles $4.48 5.1 cents
Havoline Group III/
Hydrocracked 148 5000 Miles $3.48 4.1 cents
Quaker State Group III/
Hydrocracked 148 12.27% 5000 Miles $3.97 4.6 cents
JET
COMMON 5W-30 SYNTHETIC OILS
Product Name Base Viscosity Index Pour Point °C (°F) Volatility % Weight Loss Four Ball Wear TBN Service Life Suggested Cost (Qt) Cost/10 Miles
Para. 1 Para. 3
Amsoil
XL-7500 (XLF) Group III/
Hydrocracked 196 -51 (-60) 8.8% 0.35 0.38 10.1 7500 Miles/
6 Months $5.20 4.0 cents
Amsoil (ASL) Group IV/
POA 182 -51 (-60) 6.9% 0.35 0.40 >11.0 25,000 Miles/1 Year $5.85 2.6 cents
Mobil 1 Group IV/
PAO 168 -48 (-54) 9.2% 0.35 0.60 8.5 Mfg. Rec. $4.78 3.7 cents
Pennzoil Synthetic Group III/
Hydrocracked 161 -48 (-54) 5.7% 0.40 0.60 10.0 Mfg. Rec. $4.49 3.6 cents
Valvoline SynPower Group III/
Hydrocracked 164 -44 (-47) 13.1% 0.35 0.55 8.9 Mfg. Rec. $4.48 3.6 cents
Castrol Syntec Group III/
Hydrocracked 147 -39 (-38) 10.0% 0.40 0.61 10.0 Mfg. Rec. $4.47 3.6 cents
Quaker State Full Synthetic Group III/
Hydrocracked 183 -46 (-51) 10.2% 0.35 0.55 7.7 Mfg. Rec. $3.97 3.2 cents
COMMON 10W-30 SYNTHETIC OILS
Product Name Base Viscosity Index Volatility % Weight Loss Four Ball Wear TBN Service Life Suggested Cost (Qt) Cost/10 Miles
Amsoil
XL-7500 (XLT) Group III/
Hydrocracked 163 4.7% 0.38 10.2 7500 Miles/
6 Months $5.20 4.0 cents
Amsoil (ATM) Group IV/
POA 167 6.6% 0.35 >12.2 25,000 Miles/1 Year $5.85 2.6 cents
Mobil 1 Group IV/
PAO 147 11.1% 0.35 8.5 5000 Miles $4.78 5.4 cents
Castrol Group III/
Hydrocracked 159 5.47% 6.81 5000 Miles $4.48 5.1 cents
Shell Group III/
Hydrocracked 140 5000 Miles $4.97 5.6 cents
Pennzoil Group III/
Hydrocracked 150 9.5% 0.65 7.18 5000 Miles $4.49 5.1 cents
Valvoline Group III/
Hydrocracked 140 8.3% 0.40 6.85 5000 Miles $4.48 5.1 cents
Havoline Group III/
Hydrocracked 148 5000 Miles $3.48 4.1 cents
Quaker State Group III/
Hydrocracked 148 12.27% 5000 Miles $3.97 4.6 cents
JET
Last edited by JETPILOT; Oct 22, 2006 at 12:55 AM.
Originally Posted by Sharif@Forged
We carry two types of motor oil. Their 8100 X-Cess line, which is priced around the level of Redline or Royal Purple. Then there is the racing oil called Competition 300V. Motul claims some incredible change intervals with the 300V, so the higher cost would likely be offset by longer change intervals. They are located here: http://www.forgedperformance.com/store/home.php?cat=278
FYI, I used to run Mobil 1, and I've taken apart of couple of engines that used the oil as well. Honestly, there was no meaningful bearing or journal wear that I could detect. All modern oils provide outstanding levels of protection. But on really expensive engines, I don't want the best oil...I want the best of THE BEST.
FYI, I used to run Mobil 1, and I've taken apart of couple of engines that used the oil as well. Honestly, there was no meaningful bearing or journal wear that I could detect. All modern oils provide outstanding levels of protection. But on really expensive engines, I don't want the best oil...I want the best of THE BEST.

lol, what about the Top Secret oil? what is it? 15 bucks a quart? 20? I can't imagine it protects the engine that much better.
I have the Amsoil with 1 yr 25k recomended change interval. I cahnged it at 10k last time, and the oil looked great when I took it out. I saved a quart to send it out for testing.
I have the Amsoil with 1 yr 25k recomended change interval. I cahnged it at 10k last time, and the oil looked great when I took it out. I saved a quart to send it out for testing.
Originally Posted by undrgnd
Here's something you may have missed in the owners manual: Check your oil level regularly. Hope it helps. I would say, regardless of whether it was in the past, or going forward, if you show up at the dealship 3 qts low, it's going to take a truck load of lawyers, money and guns to get Nissan to warranty a new engine, whether it's seized or not.
Originally Posted by bb319675
HAHAHA... a little OT but have you guys all looked at Rickdogg's avatar closely? (upside down)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post





