Thank you MRC
Originally Posted by Crom
Thats one reason to go greddy instead of aps....
Just FYI.
Originally Posted by Alberto
Julians generosity? I think what he did was commendable, and expected of a well known and respected shop owner in the community. Regardless of how I/others feel about him, he takes care of his customers, shamrock was just being a smart a$$.
Originally Posted by rrmedicx
Basically 2 rod bearings failed and 2 main bearings failed. Once disassembled we found a lot of (bearing) metal sinders coating the oil pan, so more than likely some metal may have gotten into the turbo and POOF!
Dead Turbo!
Dead Turbo!
the bearing issue unfortunately is not unheard of at all. There are lots of combinations of bearings that these motors will accept...I forget the total number of permiatations there are but it's more than your average motor for sure. It's very easy to make an "oops" during assembly, and install the wrong one. While it probably would never rear its head during normal use, as soon as you put any sort of meaningful boost through it and things get up to temperature, the nasty stuff starts happening.
Which 2 rod bearings and which 2 mains failed?
I know Randy personally, He is a cool guy..I met Julian a few times and he is cool also!! Just to clarify, Julian assisted in a warranty for a product not even purchased in his store. The turbo kit was purchased from Noah, who never helped Randy warranty the turbos, but simply asked for pictures of the turbos, that he never even sent over to Tim at Greddy.
Julian went well above and beyond for Randy in this situation FYI.
Julian went well above and beyond for Randy in this situation FYI.
Originally Posted by Alberto
Julians generosity? I think what he did was commendable, and expected of a well known and respected shop owner in the community. Regardless of how I/others feel about him, he takes care of his customers, shamrock was just being a smart a$$.
Originally Posted by buzzardmountain
I didn't think the OP was a customer of MRC....bought his Greddy kit from Noah and engine from Kyle.....right?
Originally Posted by Z1 Performance
glad you are making progress
the bearing issue unfortunately is not unheard of at all. There are lots of combinations of bearings that these motors will accept...I forget the total number of permiatations there are but it's more than your average motor for sure. It's very easy to make an "oops" during assembly, and install the wrong one. While it probably would never rear its head during normal use, as soon as you put any sort of meaningful boost through it and things get up to temperature, the nasty stuff starts happening.
Which 2 rod bearings and which 2 mains failed?
the bearing issue unfortunately is not unheard of at all. There are lots of combinations of bearings that these motors will accept...I forget the total number of permiatations there are but it's more than your average motor for sure. It's very easy to make an "oops" during assembly, and install the wrong one. While it probably would never rear its head during normal use, as soon as you put any sort of meaningful boost through it and things get up to temperature, the nasty stuff starts happening.
Which 2 rod bearings and which 2 mains failed?
So are you saying that misplaced bearings would only show when boosted...so that means it could still be a machining error or install error?
Originally Posted by Money0veru
I know Randy personally, He is a cool guy..I met Julian a few times and he is cool also!! Just to clarify, Julian assisted in a warranty for a product not even purchased in his store. The turbo kit was purchased from Noah, who never helped Randy warranty the turbos, but simply asked for pictures of the turbos, that he never even sent over to Tim at Greddy.
Julian went well above and beyond for Randy in this situation FYI.
Julian went well above and beyond for Randy in this situation FYI.
I am however grateful that Julian has a good rapport with the Greddy guys to help make this happen. Julians approach was a bit more aggressive than what Noah was doing, but nonetheless what Noah was doing was still helpful.
no, I'm not saying it would only show when boosted, just that it's more likely too (IMHO)
at the end of the day, trying to diagnose the "why" as far as the motor is concerned is going to be impossible...but I suspect you know that already (unfortunately)
at the end of the day, trying to diagnose the "why" as far as the motor is concerned is going to be impossible...but I suspect you know that already (unfortunately)
Randy...I am glad to hear you are making progress with your rebuild. Kudos to Julian @ MRC. This is what it should be about, people with a common interest HELPING each other!!! This is a win-win for Randy & MRC. It helps get Randy get his engine rebuilt and is an opportunity for Julian to put himself out there in a positive light. Tuners/Vendors should realize that sometimes helping a customer (or potential customer) today can bring business tomorrow. Customer service is KING. We can ALL buy parts online etc and get good prices, but what makes a customer come back over & over again is the service their tuner or vendor provides. Answering tons of questions (even for stuff they don't buy), giving price estimates, trying to accomodate customer needs are the lifeline of a business. Too bad some companies feel customer service is a burden. Just my 1 1/2 c
Originally Posted by accordfreak
so on the built motor, were the bearings the incorrect size?
Would any engine builder worried about his reputation admit a mistake that would cost him/her money...Well hopefully there are still a few honest people out there. I put my trust in Kyle and he is helping me out any way he can to get the new up and running. Kyle has already offered to not only take back the short block, but my long block for complete and thorough evaluation. He is not charging me for the tear-down or reassembly of the long block.
Thanks Adrian. Very True, customer service is big, especially in this expensive Z world. I appreciate the support.
Originally Posted by buzzardmountain
I didn't think the OP was a customer of MRC....bought his Greddy kit from Noah and engine from Kyle.....right?
alberto would have been right if the OP was what He is for Forged or Function, a Customer

...cuase then its "a must" that a top shop should take care of their customers
Originally Posted by IIQuickSilverII
yeap....
alberto would have been right if the OP was what He is for Forged or Function, a Customer
...cuase then its "a must" that a top shop should take care of their customers
alberto would have been right if the OP was what He is for Forged or Function, a Customer

...cuase then its "a must" that a top shop should take care of their customers
I'm not sure what your comment above was directed to accomplish. Is alberto the Front man for Forged? I don't really know, but I do know that he is a customer. Is Alberto sponsored by Forged? I don't know. I'm sure he would like to be, just as I would like to be sponsored and not pay for parts. I'm sure you know what that is like. Isn't your car being prepared by someone else or am I mistaken?
Anyway, lets not loose focus here.
Originally Posted by rrmedicx
You don't have to be "special" to get good customer service. Good customer service "should" be granted to everyone...who pays. Its a shop owners choice whether or not good customer service is granted. As a customer we deserve 100% of what we pay for. I am not paying for attitude or unwanted comments. I just want what I pay for. I paid for an engine, a Turbo, an exhaust. Almost everything worked. I now have to take care of things one at a time. Julians customer service granted to a customer helped me.
I'm not sure what your comment above was directed to accomplish. Is alberto the Front man for Forged? I don't really know, but I do know that he is a customer. Is Alberto sponsored by Forged? I don't know. I'm sure he would like to be, just as I would like to be sponsored and not pay for parts. I'm sure you know what that is like. Isn't your car being prepared by someone else or am I mistaken?
Anyway, lets not loose focus here.
I'm not sure what your comment above was directed to accomplish. Is alberto the Front man for Forged? I don't really know, but I do know that he is a customer. Is Alberto sponsored by Forged? I don't know. I'm sure he would like to be, just as I would like to be sponsored and not pay for parts. I'm sure you know what that is like. Isn't your car being prepared by someone else or am I mistaken?
Anyway, lets not loose focus here.
That would be like having Honda warranty a Nissan. GT Spec perhaps should have moved a bit more swiftly on helping you out,but either way the issue is taken care of for you!



