I really did not want to ask but I'm so lost. What size tires would be best? Wheels are 18x9.5 +16 front and 18x10.5 +16 rear. I really don't like the stretched tire look either. The car is 03 Z Track at stock height. I was thinking 245/40 front and 275/40 rear but really not sure! Thank you in advance!

 

255/40
275/40

 

Thanks for the quick response. I was also considering 255 for the front so It pretty much confirms what I was thinking.

 

The front will have a square shoulder, rear will be rounded just a minimal amount

 

Agreed all day long on the 255 & 275 recommendation. Just one FWIW thought...+16 on a 9.5" out-front has "some poke," that "rounded" 245 might be appealing. But...but...talkin' mm's, I'm 255 up-front on a 9.5" and its excellent fitment/performance.