I am looking in to getting one of these and just wanted to know if anybody had anything good or bad to say about either one.

 

What do you need it for ????

 

i didn't know either company made a pan for the HR/VHR

 

A couple of advantages are each carry about an extra quart of oil and are finned (the aps fins are more apparent) so that helps with keeping the oil cool. The aps one is baffled to keep oil around the pickup, I don’t know about the stillen I can't find any pics of the inside. The main advantage to both of them is that they (safely) drop the oil level under the crank to keep it from frothing the oil. At least that’s my understanding of it.

APS
Stillen

 

Not sure how this got moved to the VQ37HVR section I am running an 04 base VQ35DE.


---Edit--- Thanks for moving it to the right thread

 

um, whatever makes you feel better

 

The drawback to the APS pan right now is getting one. I'm not sure that anyone has any in the U.S. currently.

 

aps pans strip vary easily and are hard to have not leak, jst from my personal experience

 

Cool. Thanks for the info. Anybody else have any experience with either pan?